McClelland and Generalissimo Franco Are Still Dead

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

60 Fresh Savinelli Pipes
11 Fresh Ropp Pipes
18 Fresh AKB Meerschaum Pipes
12 Fresh Jacono Pipes
3 Fresh Il Cerchio Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

khiddy

Can't Leave
Jun 21, 2024
406
2,273
South Bend, Indiana
blog.hallenius.org
Your feelings about the situation are based on a profound lack of information.

Shopping mall B&M "blends" that are a tossed together in a salad bowl combination of true blends is NOT what McClelland did.

Blend "recipes" are just the fist step of a multi-step process, all of which require extensive knowledge, experience, labor, and machinery to perform.

Not to mention that sourcing the same raw leaf that McC used would literally not be possible.
We all know that, being an agricultural product, leaves change from crop to crop, so our inability to "sourc[e] the same raw leaf" is a red herring of an argument.

The unique processes and blending recipes that they discovered, developed, and employed, though, are something that they could've/should've shared, or at least documented for a future generation to employ. Not doing so is the same as having all of their possessions buried with them to ensure that no one else will ever benefit. And that's why I say it's selfish. (Of course, perhaps they have secretly documented their processes to be released or at least passed on for a future generation, and if so, I will happily eat my words and beg forgiveness for my current comments. But until and unless we know that they did, my opinion stands.)

For the record, if as rumored STG destroys the Sutliff processing equipment to preclude any other company from buying and using it to produce products that they are killing off in the name of short-term shareholder returns, that would be the exact same thing. And it's just as execrable.
 

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
6,101
16,735
We all know that, being an agricultural product, leaves change from crop to crop, so our inability to "sourc[e] the same raw leaf" is a red herring of an argument.

The unique processes and blending recipes that they discovered, developed, and employed, though, are something that they could've/should've shared, or at least documented for a future generation to employ. Not doing so is the same as having all of their possessions buried with them to ensure that no one else will ever benefit. And that's why I say it's selfish. (Of course, perhaps they have secretly documented their processes to be released or at least passed on for a future generation, and if so, I will happily eat my words and beg forgiveness for my current comments. But until and unless we know that they did, my opinion stands.)

For the record, if as rumored STG destroys the Sutliff processing equipment to preclude any other company from buying and using it to produce products that they are killing off in the name of short-term shareholder returns, that would be the exact same thing. And it's just as execrable.

You THINK you know what you're talking about, but you don't.

For example ---

The equipment that was used by McC and Sutliff was not destroyed to "preclude any other company from buying and using it" but because federal safety regulations have become more strict since it was made, which means anyone who bought it and had an employee injured by it, could SUE them for HAVING SOLD it.

To be legally protected, machinery like that not only can't be sold, but its destruction must be witnessed by someone who is certified, and with a full documentation follow-up.

The tobacco and processes side of things was equally intractable and much more complicated.

How do I know? What is my source? I have known Mike and Mary for decades, and they live within walking distance of me. My mother was a teacher of his in elementary school.

They are two of the finest humans I have ever met in my life, full stop. I could tell you stories of their generosity you literally wouldn't believe. Events I witnessed first hand.

So give it a rest, OK?

Describing their behavior as "selfish" and "excreable" COULD NOT BE farther from the truth.

Again, (and hopefully for the last time): You THINK you know what you're talking about, but you don't.