Let's Settle It....Highest Quality Tobacco's ??

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

pstlpkr

Lifer
Dec 14, 2009
9,694
31
Birmingham, AL
@Flyguy
I can honestly say that I have never tried that particular blend.

I still find it hard to believe that it actually exists. :D

 

sirsmokesalot

Starting to Get Obsessed
Feb 4, 2012
129
0
North Carolina
@rothnh....Great comment! That was my purpose for starting this thread. To find out who uses the finest tobacco in their blends, and who doesn't. There's a HUGE difference between a GL Pease Blend and a drug store

blend right? I know when I buy tobacco in bulk...and then buy tobacco in tins, the difference in quality is the

first thing I usually notice. Not always....But most of the time.

 
Jul 15, 2011
2,363
31
Leaf quality among pipe tobacco blends is going to be universally higher than tobacco leaf in cigarettes. Cigarette tobacco leaves are shredded, processed all to hell, then treated with who in the hell knows what to make them more addictive and keep people coming back for more. Comparing pipe tobacco leaf to cigars is like comparing apples to oranges. They are both good on their own merits, and different people like them for different reasons, but you cant really call one BETTER than another, it all boils down to personal taste. There are some people who love Cornell and Diehl and GL Pease, and there are some people who like Hearth and Home and Dunhill. Neither are wrong, but the importance is that ALL pipe tobacco blenders should use the highest quality leaf they have available to them in order to maintain a quality product, but whether or not everyone is going to LIKE them is another matter entirely. Almost all pipe tobacco is high quality tobacco, even though some of it may register just a bit lower than others in the grand scheme of things.

 

igloo

Lifer
Jan 17, 2010
4,083
5
woodlands tx
Burley gets a bad rap as do any blends that come in a plastic or foil containers . Heck people even complain about the different vintages of Dunhill as for me why anyone would smoke Lakeland blends is beyond me .They smell like armpit and cheap perfume to me . But unless you are smoking sheet tobacco chances are pretty good that the base leaf is good . All of the blenders do a great job with what they have to work with and like wine the vintages vary from year to year . Explore and have fun with the hobby , find what you like and do not let anyone tell you any different . So get out there and explore and have fun and enjoy . That is unless your head is stuck so far up your a... that you can not pull it out . :nana:

 
May 31, 2012
4,295
37
samcoffeeman -

Good eye, however, I will defend my alternate spelling of the word.

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=plebeian&allowed_in_frame=0

That spelling falls in line with pleb and plebby which are slang words in current usage.
“Plebes autem ea dicatur in qua gentes patriciae non insunt”
I wasn't talking about Romans, so historical accuracy is a moot point, although as noted on the etymology dictionary, even in Latin the later use was pleb which superseded plebe.

------------------------------------------------------
As for The Sophisticate, he is not my creation. I was tickled with his writings when I recently found them on the ASP list. He was active circa 1999/2000. I dunno why I posted that anyway, which was out of context here. My humble apologies.

------------------------------------------------------
I think the best leaf is from Kentucky and Malawi.

 

fitzy

Lifer
Nov 13, 2012
2,937
28
NY
+1 Cigrmaster. I also would personally add Hearth & Home to that list as I find their Balkan/English to be some of the best.

 

sirsmokesalot

Starting to Get Obsessed
Feb 4, 2012
129
0
North Carolina
Thanks gentlemen for all your input. As in anything else in life....you get what you pay for. As for me...I will continue on with my search for as one person commented here....It's the journey itself that's the most fun!

 

kashmir

Lifer
May 17, 2011
2,712
70
Northern New Jersey
For the past several years, my snout has been rooting about in the cellars of Cornell & Diehl. With much success I might add.
2769777d.jpg


 

mustanggt

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 6, 2012
819
4
Good day and greetings, all you red-eye unwashed plebians of the pipe...
...it has come to my attention via top secret channels through clandestine interchange that your paltry forum has fallen into pitiful disarray. This is apparently because there are no possessors of specialized knowledge left among you that are willing to withstand the foul stench of your pointless inane postings and uncleaned basket pipes filled with non- vintage drugstore tobaccos.
Worse yet, your ceaseless worship of very mild crossover blends like the limp wristed Frog Mortons give any pause to actually take you seriously.
Buying, filling, lighting, and actually smoking such an esoteric item as a briar root pipe seems, in the minds of those who know, to be beyond you. You wallow in the dark valley of corncob pipes (gasp!), Carter Hall "tobacco", (double gasp!!) and grubby Bic lighters. And you even seem to enjoy this squalor!!
Alas, how has this come to pass?
Not one exquisite hand-tooled mastodon tamper amongst you!
Then again, such luxuries would be wasted upon you, as you cannot discern the subtle nuances encased within the mythic discontinued blends, of which I affectionately only smoke.
As I recline on my bespoke calfskin settee, smoking a 1924 Dunhill Zulu Magnum filled with George Dobie & Son Paisley Flake from deep within my vast stores of ancient leaf (all cutter tops of course), I ponder the dilemma. How can such barbarian pipe people such as yourselves be brought into the bright light of fine high grade pipes and the truest ultra fine tobaccos?
The problem is especially difficult because those that profess to be keepers of the specialized knowledge are so horrified at your unkempt condition that they will not even don a hazardous waste protection suit and mingle with you members of the newbie masses. Indeed, there is a faint noxious odor coming through my gold plated keyboard, my vidscreen morphs into an eldritch horror of indecipherable illiteracies upon my happenstance visit here.
I will have to have my faithful manservant, Manchester, disinfect it later, after my usual lunch of cold Maine lobster salad, followed by Napoleon brandy and a bowl of original 1963 Balkan Sobranie Smoking Mixture in a 3 foot meerschaum carved by a Turkish disciple of A.Rodin, lighted and supported by two lovely honeydrippers dressed in traditional harem girl garb.
What to do? What to do? Indeed it is a serious matter. How can you cretins be brought up to the level of those true masters in the highest fine art of pipe smoking that shun your very existence?
Suggestions, anyone?
How can you ever gain the required obscure errata necessary to become an authentic connoisseur?
Alas, there may be no hope.
Now, off you go to smolder your steamy over-sauced cavendishes!
The Sophisticate
Post Script:

Of the over 36,700 individual blends that have been recorded in the Duke Street White Spot shop “My Mixture Book”, I will squash all dissent by stating that the finest blend ever available is my personal amalagation known as My Mixture #Zero a.k.a. Alpha-Omega Shell Flake, of that there is no doubt.
Mr. lowercase, I do believe I've never enjoyed being insulted so much before in my life!!! Such eloquence in usage of the Queens English!!! Bravo sir!!! :clap: :clap: :clap: :puffpipe: :mrgreen:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.