Let's Make A Top 5 OTC's Thread!

[petes03]

This may have already been done before, if it has I apologize but I haven't seen one.
Here we go;

1) Sugar Barrel

2) Carter Hall

3) Prince Albert

4) Smoker's Pride Black Cavendish

5) Half & Half

 

[andrew]

1- Amphora red

 

[leacha]

This is my order of preference:
1) Sugar Barrel

2) Captain Black "Dark"

3) Walnut*

4) Carter Hall

5) Prince Albert "Red Can"
*see my other post.

 

[zekest]

This in my order of preference if on an island with pipe and matches:
1) Prince Albert in the Red Can

2) Walnut

3) Captain Black Dark

4) Carter Hall

5) Captain Black Original (White pouch)

 

[petes03]

Keep em' coming guys! I see Prince Albert and Carter Hall seems to be on common ground with most, so far.

 

[05venturer]

1) Carter Hall

2) Walnut

3) Prince Albert

4) Sugar Barrel

5) CB Dark

 

[leacha]

For the past month I've been on a Burley smoke and haven't had much of anything else. Outside of ordering some more MC 5100 Red Cake (always need to replenish right?) I've thought about going through all of the OTC blends I could get. One that really peaks my interest is the Kentucky Club "mild". If I see it on this list I will need to order a tub.

 

[wilson]

Walnut

Carter Hall

The Prince

Sir Walter

Granger

 

[05venturer]

holy crap Roth are we related?? It looks like I need to try to get a hold of some Granger!! :rofl:

 

[misterlowercase]

1) St. Bruno

2) Warrior Plug

3) Condor Long Cut

4) Mick McQuaid Plug

5) Walnut Flake
:wink:

UK newsagent edition!

 

[unclefester13]

Fox and Hound (Tobacco Galleria)

Night Cap (Tobacco Galleria)

Captain Black (White)

Borkum Riff (Original)

Midnight Smoke (Tobacco Galleria)

 

[terrygoldman123]

1) Capt. Black-Dark-Black pouch
2. Borkum Riff-whiskey
3) Fox & Hound-Tobacco Galleria
4) Carter Hall
5) Alsbo Gold-nice smoke and cheap

 

[petes03]

Keep em' coming guys!

 

[nsfisher]

CH

PA

50% CH and 50% Walnut

Sugar Barrel

Walnut

 

[metalheadycigarguy]

1. Granger

2. Granger

3. Granger

4. Granger

5. Granger
Is there anything else? ::