Less is More

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

The Libertine

Can't Leave
Jul 19, 2024
313
1,132
NYC
As for pipes, I really like a lot of them, but am pretty controlled in what I buy. I’ll buy a brand new pipe once every few years and my max spend limit is $300 (tho a Castillo might be an exception down the road). I’ll buy estate and antique pipes here and there though if the price and condition are right.

See I prefer to spend money on tobacco now, figure out my palate, and build my cellar, which is close to where I want it. Prices and availability of tobacco keep changing for the worse whereas for pipes not so much. Hopefully after a few big TAD purchases this year in prep for some tax changes I’ll be set and then can buy a few more nicer pipes.

But like one of you said, it’s akin to having a stocked liquor cabinet and I like having choices even if it means I might have more than enough.
I am the same when it comes to tobacco. I can never have enough and it provides me with a variety.
 

Grangerous

Lifer
Dec 8, 2020
3,514
14,595
East Coast USA
I get it. I enjoy burley and the plainer it is, the better.

It’s the flavorings and additives that turn me off of most blends.

I’ve developed an expectation that I’m going to enjoy my pipe and I’m perfectly fine with getting exactly what I expect.

Whenever I try something new, like yesterday; I cracked open a 2014 tin of Sutliff 1849 Virginia Perique. Yes, I could taste the citrus and plum and smell the vinegary tin note, but it’s not my “thing.”

So I grabbed a cob that had some 5 Brothers and just smoked and smoked surrounded by nothing more than simple leaf.

There’s a reason men started putting fire to tobacco. It’s a simple pleasure.
 

MisterBadger

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 6, 2024
610
4,477
Ludlow, UK
Having only recently returned to pipe smoking after many years' abstinence, I find I am already fighting off PAD, having acquired a dozen pipes of varying denominations to see what suits me best. Similarly - though not as acutely - I am struggling against the siren call of TAD, whilst trying out different Va/Per blends in order to narrow down later to maybe two or three which afford me the most pleasure. In other words, my intention is to acheive a less-is-more state, but to do that I find a preliminary expansion is necessary in order to effect a reduction. One other thing: I generally limit myself to one pipe a day, never more than two - and those I find I really enjoy. I try and devote myself to the experience: as the old farmer said, when asked what he did in the evenings: "Sometimes I sits and thinks, and other times, I just sits." Substitute 'smokes' for thinks', and that's where I'm at at present, and don't excpect to change.
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,803
31,521
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
Barry Schwartz wrote a book about the paradox of choice that gets at exactly what you are talking about re too much choice. Here is aTed Talk Barry gave on the subject that I really like.
important trick learn to appreciate what you have. It's amazing how far that can go.
 

Pipke

Can't Leave
Aug 3, 2024
419
1,320
East of Cleveland, Ohio. USA
I am down to two regular tobaccos and a few occasional leftovers. My regular pipe rotation is down to 3.
I have to sort the remainder and decide what to do at some point when I get time. I am envious of those who have already accomplished this task.
I'm still enjoying the ride too much as a new pipe smoker to be envious. But my goal is like yours. Eventually, my journey will wind down to a few blends and a smattering of favorite pipes. I suspect I'll always have a few tins of "treat" tobaccos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FalconForever

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,803
31,521
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
I agree- appreciate what you’ve got, it’s probably pretty great.
I learned that lesson a few times but the first, was when I was little and would go to a rich kids house and be all like you have that toy and that one too.... And they'd be like yeah it's boring. The little bastards would seem to get less out of a mass of great toys then I could get out of the one or two new toys I got months ago.
 

Hillcrest

Lifer
Dec 3, 2021
3,793
19,265
Connecticut, USA
I'm still enjoying the ride too much as a new pipe smoker to be envious. But my goal is like yours. Eventually, my journey will wind down to a few blends and a smattering of favorite pipes. I suspect I'll always have a few tins of "treat" tobaccos.
I started with cigars, then pipes, then cigarettes for too many years, now back to pipes. Unfortunately, I have an eye for quality and bought several very good quality pipes when I was young. I then figured out what I liked and bought a few more. Some have some sentimental value, believe it or not. Of the 25 pipes I have (all but one are bents) there are nine (older) that are 'perfect' in my opinion ... the rest (newer) are merely great and don't get used that often. None bad. Those are the ones I may pass on. I mainly smoke Sutliff 507-C and Lane 1-Q now. The 507 fills my virginia craving and the Lane 1-Q fills my sweet craving. The rest are like desserts you try once in awhile and enjoy but don't fill a craving. That's just me though. Each smoker has to find out what they like by trying various blends and pipes. Then once you know what you like stick with it and scrap the rest. Just my two cents adjusted for current inflation ... that plus 5 bucks may get you a coffee somewhere ! ;) :ROFLMAO: P.S. Surprisingly, or maybe not, my least expensive pipes are the ones that smoke the best but then they were purchased years ago when briar and craftsmanship were better (imho).
 

MisterBadger

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 6, 2024
610
4,477
Ludlow, UK
A thought about fewer pipes: I was trawling through eBay recently, looking for pipe racks, and it struck me that the older ones are generally made to accommodate no more than six pipes - that's at most one for every day of the week, including the one in current use in your pocket, and no more, assuming they were always intended for one man's personal use... or (as my grandmother once related to me when she was a young girl in her father's house - this would have been in the early 1900s - kept for visitors as well as oneself: he kept a selection of new clays, particularly for Sundays, when after Church or Chapel, he would hold court by the fireside and he and his friends would smoke and argue about religion, politics and Life, The Universe, And Everything. He worked in a steel mill, had six children and I reckon that wealth and pleasure to him was half a dozen clays and a few fills of baccy to be generous with.