No I’m not saying they do use PG but they use something. Something oily it seems to me. I’m not a fan of cavendish aromatics but I’ve smoked my share of Kendal black cherry. Palace gate etc… those seem like maybe PG but I don’t get that particular flavor that PG has. I’m not trying to badmouth Gawith, they are by far my favorite manufacturer and their products are historical. I’m also not an expert in tobacco, pipes or anything really but I’ve been fortunate to smoke many different things. But there’s something in FVF, St James, best brown, dark plug that makes smoking them more of a task than the usual flakes. I’ve left dark plug out to dry for weeks as experimentation and even though it drys there’s an oily aspect to it that doesn’t dry. I don’t expect Rachel to tell us or really even care much. I’ll continue to smoke to the end.