I like the tobacco more than I like either Lovecraft or Grindcore. But I don't love the tobacco. I don't hate it, either.
Some of the notes suggested here resonate with my experience of it:
Plum, grape, rum, musty red wine, rotting fruit.
All of these are getting at it.
I think that what's confusing is this:
Typically, when flavors don't harmonize, they clash.
If we don't like what a set flavors do together, we DISlike what they do together.
But Kadath brings together a number flavors that neither harmonize nor clash, and it leaves our brains straining to process and categorize what we're experiencing.
I intend to keep going back to my plug, every once in a while, for a change of pace. Maybe it will come together for me one of these times. I guess it's interesting and likeable enough that I still want to do that.