Just Bought a Fancier Tamper

[HRPufnstuf]

I seem to be a minority here but my go to desk tamper is a Rattray's slim Caber. Pros: round concave foot makes mounding simple and easily clears excess cake from the bowl. Cons: the pick is a little fat, it has no scoop. Some people dislike threaded pipe tools, but at my desk this is not an issue, I often leave it open on the ash tray.

 

[Egg Shen]

I’m no 8deco expert but I have a few. The one you depict is taller and has an ever so slightly smaller diameter tamp, maybe 1 millimeters difference. My gold one seems to be in the same class as yours. My Goldie is 24.19g. My colored plastic ones are between 14.44 and 15.2 g The gold one has problems fitting deep into the narrow chamber pipes but those others seem to have just enough clearance for 95% of my pipes

 

[Egg Shen]

I also enjoy other styles.

 

[Bassman65]

I seem to be a minority here but my go to desk tamper is a Rattray's slim Caber. Pros: round concave foot makes mounding simple and easily clears excess cake from the bowl. Cons: the pick is a little fat, it has no scoop. Some people dislike threaded pipe tools, but at my desk this is not an issue, I often leave it open on the ash tray.

View attachment 269390

I have both the Rattray and 8deco. I like them both. 8deco has the vented dome foot, while the Rattray doesn’t. I don’t really notice a difference when using though. 8deco also has the scoop at one end. The pick on the 8deco is rounded at the end and wider. The Rattray’s pick is thinner and sharper edged. I find the Rattray's pic easier to get into the nooks and crannies of a cob - especially when removing damp bottle or unsmoked tobacco. So from a functionality standpoint they both have their pros and cons. From a cost standpoint, the 8deco has the edge.

Personally,I love the size, weight and looks of the Rattray better. Mine has Celtic inspired design elements and a stylized Celtic dog head that looks like my boxer. Lol.

In the end, buy them both

 

[didimauw]

I'm not sure if they are all the same, but here's what I am showing...

View attachment 269348View attachment 269349

22g weight and about 4.5" length

I'll have to look for mine and weigh it too!

 

[RobNYC]

For those who have the 8decos, are they all the same length and weight? I’m finally interested in getting a nicer tamper but want it to have some weight and length as well. It looks like there are heavy shorter tampers around (like in brass) but not ones that have both length and weight. Would the 8decos be what I’m looking for? Thanks!

They are not all the same length and weight. I think this might appeal to you if you are looking for weight And length.

https://www.smokingpipes.com/accessories/pipe-tampers-and-tools/moreinfo.cfm?product_id=116349

I have one of these and it has pretty good weight to it and a good reach. They do eventually come back in stock.

 

[TheIronMonkey]

They are not all the same length and weight. I think this might appeal to you if you are looking for weight And length.

https://www.smokingpipes.com/accessories/pipe-tampers-and-tools/moreinfo.cfm?product_id=116349

I have one of these and it has pretty good weight to it and a good reach. They do eventually come back in stock.

I have that one, but still have yet to use it. I thought it would be good to take on the go, but I usually smoke only at home.

 

[RobNYC]

I have that one, but still have yet to use it. I thought it would be good to take on the go, but I usually smoke only at home.

LOL. Same story here, 98% of the time at home, although I have used it a few times.

 

[jbfrady]

I'm with @kcghost on this one. Even though I don't leave home with nice tampers I can't seem to keep track of them unless I give them an assigned spot. The one pipe nail I ever bought, however, I've had on hand for nearly half my life. I could try to misplace it I guess, but I'm afraid that would just piss it off.

 

[carmell269]

I love fancy tampers, enough that I’m now making and selling my own. I had another thread on here yesterday but it was deleted by the admin, guess I didn’t have enough posts (10 years as a member doesn’t count).

 

[anotherbob]

I love fancy tampers, enough that I’m now making and selling my own. I had another thread on here yesterday but it was deleted by the admin, guess I didn’t have enough posts (10 years as a member doesn’t count). View attachment 276779View attachment 276781

nope it requires a certain number of posts.

 

[hoosierpipeguy]

I purchased several "nicer" tampers from Smoking Pipes. They are pretty but functionally do not compare to a Czech Pipe Tool, at least to me they don't.

 

[PaulTheScandinavian]

for the value and overall quality >Rattray's

 

[Sigmund]

Ive also found the Czech tools every one gives away to be the most convenient.

 

[didimauw]

Ive also found the Czech tools every one gives away to be the most convenient.

I keep one in my jeans 5th pocket next to my old boy at all times.