How To Tell If A Pipe is Clay Or Meer
- Thread starter Dshift
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
I’d say Peterson wouldn’t/hasn’t made a clay pipe with a metal band and vulcanite stem.
It’s VERY rare to see a clay pipe dressed up like that, in that shape.
Maybe there’s an example or two out there, but in general, the vast majority of clay pipes are straight and in the Belge/Cutty shape family.
It’s VERY rare to see a clay pipe dressed up like that, in that shape.
Maybe there’s an example or two out there, but in general, the vast majority of clay pipes are straight and in the Belge/Cutty shape family.
That's a Meer. Meers are carved from a block, Clays are molded and fired. I suppose it could be possible to have some kind of figure Clay, but every one I've seen is smooth. The walls are thinner. And if you really want to tell, smoke the pipes. If the bowl gets too hot to hold, it's a Clay. Unless, of course, you're putting like a madman. The pipes below are all Clays.
Cough, cough… Well… actually Peterson made just that from about 1896 to 1940.
But the above pipe is not one of them. 
I should’ve read more before posting. In the link I added to the above post, M Irwin stated they did them off and on into the seventies.
Not meaning to derail @Dshift’s thread, but it’s good info for anyone that pops in on it.
Not meaning to derail @Dshift’s thread, but it’s good info for anyone that pops in on it.
In the back of my mind I just KNEW it would be so.Cough, cough… Well… actually Peterson made just that from about 1896 to 1940.
View attachment 412733
Please don't worry about derailing my threads, I already found my answer and now I am just learning interesting information.
It is a clay pipe. Peterson made on the past clay pipe and never made meer as export of raw meer was banned by Turkey government to protect local carvers which is why the only meer available are from Turkey carvers. Interesting link below about Peterson clay pipes.
rebornpipes.com
Peterson’s Clay pipes – rebornpipes
Posts about Peterson’s Clay pipes written by rebornpipes
rebornpipes.com
Peterson made LOADS of meerschaums. Mostly African block… And that is definitely not a clay.It is a clay pipe. Peterson made on the past clay pipe and never made meer as export of raw meer was banned by Turkey government to protect local carvers which is why the only meer available are from Turkey carvers. Interesting link below about Peterson clay pipes.
Peterson’s Clay pipes – rebornpipes
Posts about Peterson’s Clay pipes written by rebornpipes
It is a clay pipe. Peterson made on the past clay pipe and never made meer as export of raw meer was banned by Turkey government to protect local carvers which is why the only meer available are from Turkey carvers. Interesting link below about Peterson clay pipes.
Peterson’s Clay pipes – rebornpipes
Posts about Peterson’s Clay pipes written by rebornpipes
My 4 other Peterson meers disagree and don't identify as clay pipes.It is a clay pipe. Peterson made on the past clay pipe and never made meer as export of raw meer was banned by Turkey government to protect local carvers which is why the only meer available are from Turkey carvers. Interesting link below about Peterson clay pipes.
Peterson’s Clay pipes – rebornpipes
Posts about Peterson’s Clay pipes written by rebornpipes
How dare you assume what they identify as…
The only reason for my doubt was the very even coloration and that it felt colder on the touch than my other meers and I guess the unusual color mount, unusual for me at least
Well, as said if smoking gets very hot is a clay, if it stays cool is a meer but keep in mind that double walled clays are not as hot as the single walled ones, but still hotter than meer. Either way it would be a great smoker as clay and meer are my preferred. I would definitely smoke it.
I am still inclined toward a clay as that mottled appearance is the same I have on a Lepeltier clay and on the meers it is more of a gradient coloration variation. But of course I would not put my life on it.
I am still inclined toward a clay as that mottled appearance is the same I have on a Lepeltier clay and on the meers it is more of a gradient coloration variation. But of course I would not put my life on it.
Well there is only one thong to do - I will clean it up and smoke it tomorrow. I will report afterwards.