Every unfinished pipe I have is now a mellow brown, waxed or not. You're right; the pipe will do what it wants to do.I have one Peterson that’s their ‘natural’ finish. As you probably know it’s their top tier smooth pipe finish and very light in color. The bowl of this pipe was left untreated. I don’t know if being untreated has been a factor but over the course of 20 +/- bowls of Virginia flake the entire exterior has noticeably darkened. At some point soon I’m going to give it a Murphy’s soap treatment and then a coat of wax. But ultimately it’s going to do what it wants to do.
<< Snipped bits out >>