How Do You Pick Your Next Smoke?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

11 Fresh Vauen Pipes
2 Fresh Ken Dederichs Pipes
18 Fresh Estate Pipes
5 Fresh Christian Ruetz Pipes
12 Fresh Castello Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Brad H

Lifer
Dec 17, 2024
2,006
10,782
For me, I favor what I smoke for the time of the day and the heat/cold/humidity factor.

I like to start the day with cowboy coffee or early morning blend.
I transition to Va or VaPer blends until around evening where I will transition to a burley and end the day with some English.

Now in that pattern I do sometimes plan on what blend I will smoke, or sometimes load about 3-5 pipes up, forget what I have loaded them with and then play the guess what I am smoking game.

Now if it’s really cold outside and dark, let’s say around midnight, then it has to be a Lakeland blend.
 
May 2, 2018
4,121
31,888
Bucks County, PA
I usually smoke 2 bowls per day as time allows. And, usually my first bowl of the day is Haunted Bookshop.

I just finished off the last of my McClelland 2015 (which as one of my favorites). Lately, I’ve been bouncing between Old Dominion, Sixpence & FVF as my second bowl of the day. Once I’ve finished off one of the 3 listed, I’ll likely open a tin of something in a few weeks to add into the rotation. ☕
 

abecox

Part of the Furniture Now
Sep 8, 2010
757
8,043
Cleveland, OH
I only smoke a few pipes a week and I like all sorts of blends minus aromatics so I generally just go with where the spirit leads. On occasions where I can have more than one I'll either just smoke similar blends over the course of the day or I'll start with something milder like a Virginia and move up to something stouter like a Latakia blend with cigar but never the other way around.
 

Goblin_Walrus

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 1, 2025
745
10,629
Texas
It’s very moment-to-moment. Sometimes I’ll get a hankerin for a specific family of blends, but for the most part it’s just walk over to the jars, stare at the jars, and grab one. If I’m traveling I’ll only bring one or two blends, so very predictable there.
 

sardonicus87

Lifer
Jun 28, 2022
1,818
16,252
38
Lower Alabama
Typically, I'll have one tin of whatever that I'm predominantly smoking through at a time, and a few other tins of something a little contrasting to break it up on occasion.

Like recently, I was smoking Sun Bear Black Locust (2024), and halfway through the tin I cracked open XXV Reserve Dusk. Once Sun Bear was finished, I started predominantly smoking Dusk and today, I opened Brothers in Arms, though I'm still mostly smoking Dusk.

Once Dusk is done, I'll predominantly be smoking Brothers in Arms and will pick something else.

I also have a handful of others I'll swap to on occasion outside the main and the secondary, ones that keep well after opening like semois or MB Navy Flake.

However, I usually only smoke one bowl per day (that's about all I have time for). So most days it'll be the main one I am smoking, with some days being other ones. How often I switch up to a secondary or tertiary will depend a lot on how I am feeling at the time, and what the primary is (a heavy puncher or bite-prone one I might switch up more often, though with most aromatics as the primary I don't switch nearly as much).
 

SmokingInTheWind

Part of the Furniture Now
Mar 24, 2024
731
3,992
New Mexico
I focus on one 4 oz or 8 oz jar until it is empty, with an occasional bowl of something else here and there. I don’t want to store more jars so I try to free up enough to open a Mylar and transfer it to jars. I have about 48 jars. Many of the blends in the jars won’t be repurchased so I’m trying to work through them so I can use them for my standby blends. Once these blends are gone I will be a bit more free form with picking my smoke. I know, too practical.
 

ZenPipe

Lurker
Aug 3, 2025
12
17
I’m new to the hobby and have around 8 jars of different blends, mostly English with a few aros and virginias. Leaning more towards English most of the time but I appreciate pretty much all of them. Waiting to accrue enough jars and number them so I can do like somebody else on here mentioned and roll a d20 if I’m indecisive.
 

Sobrbiker

Lifer
Jan 7, 2023
6,547
89,381
Casa Grande, AZ
Sometimes I start with a blend in mind, sometimes I stare at my selection until something pops out at me, or a I grab a regular-whichever comes first.

I’m getting better at trying to smoke up “so/so” blends to free up space, but I rarely smoke any blend smoke after smoke. But some days I’ll smoke half a dozen times and not repeat.