Welcome! I get to travel out to your neck of the desert relatively often, going between Ft Stockton, Pecos, and up to Carlsbad NM. Glad you’re here!
Regarding tobacco choices, good advice so far - order a few 1 oz samples online. For that full bodied flavor experience coming from maduro cigars, I would recommend:
- C&D Bayou Morning (a Perique heavy blend that has a bit of punch to it)
- C&D Haunted Bookshop (a “classic” burley based recommendation, full flavor. Not everyone’s cup of tea, but try it fresh and again after a few weeks/months sitting in a jar)
- MacBaren HH Old Dark Fired (intro to dark fired leaf in a punchy but smooth blend)
- Low Country Virginia & Oriental (not as full bodied, but a good way to find out whether oriental flavors could be your thing)
- C&D Habana Daydream (a good crossover from cigar into Latakia, this blend has cigar leaf)
- Sutliff Match Sunrise (a good mild English, bulk “match” to Early Morning Pipe)
Take your time and enjoy the experimentation! Don’t worry about not liking someone else’s recommendations, but even if you don’t like something straight away, stick it in a jar and come back in the future, your tastes for the different leaf varietals will evolve as you experiment and transition from the cigar experience.