I've always been a Guinness man if I wanted a stout, but all this talk of Murphy's will have me picking some up next time I'm at the store. I'm usually more of a bitter/porter drinker, but I love my stouts every once in a while.
Gotta agree with gentlemanjerry... Bellhavens rules the roost for me. To be honest though I hardly ever drink anymore, and when I do I find myself going to wines and ports more and more. It's very strange. I was a beer and vodka guy since about 21 and one day I just couldn't stand them anymore....