Honestly, I have never been one for athletic shoes as casual footwear. I wear Red Wing work boots on the job because they are tough as well as comfortable. Doing flatbed type hauling, work boots are a necessity.Another thing you might consider, I wore nothing but boots for years myself, finally started wearing a pair of new balance running shoes in the truck. It makes a lot of difference at the end of the day.
Now I only wear boots when the weather is going to be nasty.
In my off hours I often wear leather loafers or leather casual shoes.