I haven't given away many pipes..The ones that I did give away though were to people just getting into pipe smoking.I gave them pipes that I liked and I knew smoked well in hopes that they would become pipe smokers.So far none of them have.Recently a fellow that I had given a very nice pipe to told me that he never smokes it.He didn't offer to return the pipe and I would never ask for it back..Is it just me or do you hate to see a pipe that you once liked a lot not being used?