Figured I'd chime in with another update and some thoughts in case anyone is still interested in this topic. It would be fun to know if anyone actually started rucking because of this discussion. I started because of a podcast a while back.
I've got a solid month of rucking behind me now. I'm on my second bag and it works much better than the first. I'm carrying right at around 45 lbs, and by the end of my 30-minute walk I do begin to feel it.
I've noticed that it really matters how I have the pack cinched up: even a slight bit more tightness on one shoulder strap makes the load carry way different and will end up fatiguing a different part of my body. Very strange, and something I'd not have suspected. I've only had my neck start hurting once and that was because (I think) I had the left strap too tight and threw off the balance. As soon as I loosened the pack and took it off, the pain left.
One consistent thing, though, is my shins hurt a bit while I'm rucking. I'd not have suspected that some weight on my back would put such strain on my shins. Again, after the load is removed it goes away and no lasting soreness lingers.
I can absolutely see the benefit/advantage of using weight plates (like GoRuck sells) in a pack rather than just loading it up with sand and a cinder block like I have done. The weight plates will ride up high in the pack and stay very close to the back, where the loose weight I have in mine has to be fitted carefully in order to work. Now that I know I'm going to stick with rucking, I might just invest in one of the high-end GoRuck packs with plates, but that will be an over $500 investment that will have to be mulled over for a while. I've already spent about $300 on bags experimenting with all this stuff. For now what I have works fine.
All said, I really do enjoy this exercise and want to keep it up, along with my morning weight-lifting. I'll also add that getting in shape at 48 after decades of the Standard American Diet (SAD) washed down with copious quantities of beer is, dare I say, a bit of a bitch. If you're younger and haven't yet added the 30 lbs or so of dad-bod, do yourself a favor and don't. It's not nearly as much fun taking it off as it was putting it on. I'm seeing some progress but it's slow going. Very slow going.
I've got a solid month of rucking behind me now. I'm on my second bag and it works much better than the first. I'm carrying right at around 45 lbs, and by the end of my 30-minute walk I do begin to feel it.
I've noticed that it really matters how I have the pack cinched up: even a slight bit more tightness on one shoulder strap makes the load carry way different and will end up fatiguing a different part of my body. Very strange, and something I'd not have suspected. I've only had my neck start hurting once and that was because (I think) I had the left strap too tight and threw off the balance. As soon as I loosened the pack and took it off, the pain left.
One consistent thing, though, is my shins hurt a bit while I'm rucking. I'd not have suspected that some weight on my back would put such strain on my shins. Again, after the load is removed it goes away and no lasting soreness lingers.
I can absolutely see the benefit/advantage of using weight plates (like GoRuck sells) in a pack rather than just loading it up with sand and a cinder block like I have done. The weight plates will ride up high in the pack and stay very close to the back, where the loose weight I have in mine has to be fitted carefully in order to work. Now that I know I'm going to stick with rucking, I might just invest in one of the high-end GoRuck packs with plates, but that will be an over $500 investment that will have to be mulled over for a while. I've already spent about $300 on bags experimenting with all this stuff. For now what I have works fine.
All said, I really do enjoy this exercise and want to keep it up, along with my morning weight-lifting. I'll also add that getting in shape at 48 after decades of the Standard American Diet (SAD) washed down with copious quantities of beer is, dare I say, a bit of a bitch. If you're younger and haven't yet added the 30 lbs or so of dad-bod, do yourself a favor and don't. It's not nearly as much fun taking it off as it was putting it on. I'm seeing some progress but it's slow going. Very slow going.