From Cobs to Clays

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

makhorkasmoker

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 17, 2021
580
1,392
Central Florida
For years, I have smoked a small rotation of cob pipes, and though I know many here love cobs, I have always had mixed feelings about them. For one thing, it takes me forever to "break in" a cob. By this I mean I will smoke many dozens or even hundreds of bowls before it begins to seem *right*-- or as close to right as it's going to get. Until then I taste wood, glue, varnish, maybe the paste used in so many of them, and most of all--cob. I have also long suspected that up until this point and even after, the cob somehow absorbs the flavors of tobacco.

I may feel this way because I smoke almost exclusively unadorned burley and burley-Turkish blends. if I smoked more aros, lat bombs, or perique heavy blends, I believe the cob taste would be less noticeable.

Anyway, the other day a cob split on me, and for the reasons I've just given, this was more than the loss of a six dollar pipe. I'd been waiting on that cob to be "right" for a year, suffering to greater or lesser degrees through the bowls.

So, when I made my last tobacco order, I decided to get a clay instead--a Markus Fohr billiard, and I am so glad I did. It has allowed me to see that with the cobs I had been missing so many flavors in both burleys and Turkish tobaccos. I had been missing for instance many, almost all, of the chocolate coco notes burley is famous for. I had been missing so much of izmir's wild funkiness.

I'm so impressed I may give up cobs forever.

Make no mistake, the clay is awkward and difficult in most of the ways clays are said to be. The stem is oddly shaped, and takes some getting used to. If I don't lick the stem, it'll stick to my lips (and I feel a bit creepy, licking a pipe stem every time I put it into my mouth). If I drop it, which I've almost done already, it'll break. And it's not the easiest thing to clean even with a skinny pipe cleaner.

That said, it's difficult to clean because it has a narrow draw, and I'm beginning to think I may prefer a narrow draw. I like the flow better than the wide-open cob. Also: although the bowl certainly gets warm, it rarely gets truly hot. It has yet to burn my fingers and the bowl feels no warmer than my cobs, most of the time.

So, I'm entering the world of clays. I may be looking into those clay pipes with horn or vulcanite stems in the near future.
 

Infantry23

Part of the Furniture Now
Nov 8, 2020
670
1,774
43
Smithsburg, Maryland
I have cobs, briars, meers, and a few clay pipes. I have one Markus Fohr billiard that I absolutely love! It gives a great flavor, doesn't burn hot, has been "durable" for a clay pipe, and just makes for a great smoke. Good luck with cobs in the future, but I'm sure that you'll really like clays moving forward!
 

Michigan_Bill

Part of the Furniture Now
Jul 14, 2021
939
3,470
Macomb County, Michigan
I do enjoy clays. As you say, there does seem to be a more "front and center" taste with them. (YMMV of course!) And there is no break-in. But it is a tad unfortunate if a clay takes a header onto a hard surface ☹️
I did just get a new cob, it's my first, looking forward to trying it out.
 

Searock Fan

Lifer
Oct 22, 2021
1,915
5,327
U.S.A.
You can't make a silk purse from a sowe's ear...as the saying goes. Instead of jumping through hoops to get a great smoke from a cheap pipe, why don't you loosen your wallet and get a quality pipe? The meercshaum suggestions above are good advice. puffy
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
15,820
29,666
45
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
maybe also try the old Dominion cobs. I have to admit I never like the way other brand smokes. I don't think they're bad, we're just not friends is all. Love the old Dominion cobs and one thing they smoke great right out the gate and they have a more concentrated draw which I am a fan of. I find the other cobs too open. Also I personally find that I detect more flavor from the Old Dominion which are now owned by the other brand but you can spot them because they have a reed stem. Oh and they're easier to clench then people think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: makhorkasmoker

Donb1972

Can't Leave
Feb 9, 2022
415
1,079
Erie, PA
I LOVE clay pipes! Those with the vulcanite and horn stems are actually very good(I have both). Those with the horn stems(at least the Old German brand)are a little small for my taste. But the vulcanite tavern style clays are excellent.