I have smoked cigars on and for about 20 years, and I found I quite liked CAO Moontrance cigars as well as some of their other cigars. I was happy to see some time ago that they came out with some of the same flavors in pipe tobacco. Unfortunately the pipe tobacco doesn't relate the same flavors as the cigars did. The main reason I assume is that the tobacco leaf used in pipe tobacco is quite different from cigar leaf. I just didn't get much similarity between them. My wife liked the cigar room note and the pipe room note, but said they didn't seem the same. Mind you, it's a nice aro smoke, but nothing great in my opinion. It's worth a try though if you like aro tobaccos, and you can make up your own mind as to what you think about it.