I like Arturo Fuente Cubanitas a lot, I've smoked more Fuentes than anything else and I must say the Cubanitas do a good job giving that AF flavor. The Oliva Señoritas are solid too, I think they do a great job as a mini Serie V
Do you happen to know the difference between a Fuente Cubanito and Exquisito? Besides 1/64th of an inch?
I'll add Joya de Nicaragua Antaño to our growing list
These are 4 X 32, and come 10 to a tin. About $2 apiece

I haven't tried these yet, just received a few tins today.
From the JdN website:
"This cigar is an ultra-robust, spicy smoke with an earthy finish, unbridled body and aroma, which showcases the authentic Nicaraguan puro."
Another good one is the Aladino Corojo Petite Corona. These are 4 X 40, so maybe pushing into small cigar territory. They come boxed by the 20-count, and are just shy of $5 apiece.
From the JRE website:
"This cigar is a “Puro” of Authentic Corojo grown in The JRE Tobacco Farm in Honduras from the original Cuban seed of Corojo."