Thanks a lot whimsy, I've seen that one - Mama Bear's Old Spice fragrance is supposed to be pretty dead on, but I haven't heard too much about its shaving properties. (Glycerine versus tallow in the original soap) The price is certainly right, though - you can't go wrong with $10 if it is a really close approximation.
It is definitely one of the best alternatives out there, though! The problem about putting an order into Mama Bear is that there are too many kinds that I want to try. I compliment you on finding out about that through a simple search, whereas I had to read through a raft of threads on a couple of different forums before discovering Aged Spice... :D
I broke down the other day and just bought an empty Old Spice shaving mug, so maybe I will just throw a puck of Aged Spice in there and just play pretend. :lol: