I think I would be squirreling mason jars away inside of new (empty/clean) paint buckets, with t shirts or something for padding. If an earthquake shattered my mason jars, I would probably be reduced to crying in the fetal position.
I could get away with one meerschaum pipe if I had to. Can smoke it as much as you like, and because it's made out of stone (sepiolite), there is no risk of burn out. Could always whittle a pipe out of cherry wood, a corn cob, or whatever if I had to. Stick a hollow reed on it and call it good. And I can't afford the bulk and weight of hauling around my 30 odd pipe collection!
A 5/32 or something a bit smaller diameter drill bit might come in handy for boring out the stem/shank of the pipe, after I eventually run out of pipe cleaners. Or the marading hordes take a fancy to arts and crafts, and use up the world's supply of pipe cleaners.
*Tobacco seeds - very necessary. I could barter tobacco all day long for whatever supplies I need. The stressfull post-apocalyptic lifestyle would probably make people want a smoke. I suppose edible vegetable seeds would come in handy, too.
Sunglasses. A drizabone leather wide brimmed hat and leather duster cloak. Thermal sweaters, ala Morpheous in The Matrix. Combat boots, with combat knives inside them. I like the Swedish fire steel idea a lot. Definetly a tomahawk (best of both worlds of an axe and a big knife). Big knife - awesomeness and interpersonal relationship intimidation factors. Swiss Army knife, which I am never without anyways.
And a flame thrower. Again, awesomeness factor... and negotiation influence factor.