Desert Island Blends

[Skippy Piper]

Lost: Samuel Gawith 1792 Flake
Shared: Gawith Hoggarth Coniston Cut Plug
My Secret Stash: Gawith Hoggarth Happy Brown Bogie

 

[tschiraldi]

Tins only presents a problem as two I would bring are bulks. So…
Lost - F&T Cut Blended Plug
Share - G&H Grousemoor
Keep - Dan Hamborger Veermaster

 

[Grangerous]

Granger Kept
Pegasus Shared
Crooner Lost

 

[Donutslinger]

I usually bring like 6 jars or so of different tobaccos in any trip longer than a day, mostly because I’m indecisive at the moment. But generally, I gravitate to one or two things;
Lose - Capstan
Share - Mixture Scottish
Horde - Ennerdale Flake.

 

[telescopes]

Lost - Star of the East
Share - Quiet Nights
Kept - Penzance

To be clear, Quiet Nights in my opinion is a superior smoke. But it’s readily available.

 

[telescopes]

In reality, on my next trip which is a month and a half bumming around Italy, Germany, Holland, and Switzerland, I will most likely be taking Telescopes, 73s, and EZ1. None of these are known to smokers other than a small select group of smokers.

Lost - EZ1
Shared - 73s
Kept - Telescopes

Because I know where some outstanding pipe shops are along the way, I will be stocking up on some wonderful Germains’s blends along the way. All of which will be kept.

 

[Zapasta]

I'd just bring all Brown Bogie and try to make my "compatriots" turn green.

 

[Philosophical Smoke]

Lost - Early Morning Pipe
Share - Escudo Navy Flake
Keep - Bayou Morning Flake