Dark Twist Replacement

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

ReformedPiper

Lurker
Dec 28, 2021
13
37
Victoria, TX
Does anyone have recommendations for a replacement for Mac Baren Dark Twist and/or Stockton?

In addition to that request, can anyone recommend similar blends to the above from C&D?

Thanks in advance!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scottmi

Terry Lennox

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 11, 2021
591
3,066
Southern California
Dark Twist and the other Mac Baren Roll cakes have a unique flavor. The only thing that may be close is Three Nuns which is apparently going to stay in production. Let's see how STG does with it. There is another hard to get tobacco called Special Curly by Peter Heinrichs that has a similar molasses flavor. But I'm afraid nothing is going to be exactly like Dark Twist.
 

Scottmi

Lifer
Oct 15, 2022
4,215
61,807
Orcas, WA
not a twist or coin cut, but as i sit here smoking some C&D folkore that is starting to get some age on it.. it is very satisfying, and not too unlike my beloved aged Stockton and Dark Twist... not the same, but.. if you like those, try this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: khiddy

Pipke

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 3, 2024
550
1,636
East of Cleveland, Ohio. USA
People are going to recommend "tastes like" or "reminds me of" blends, but we all know that there is really nothing quite like the Twist out there. For that matter, nothing quite like Old Dark Fired and Bold Kentucky either. Certainly nothing at C&D because they don't make twists (ropes) or do hot pressing. Maybe try some of their crumble cakes.

Explore Gawith and Hoggarth products if you haven't already done so. Maybe Dark Plug or Brown Bogie. It's still not the same.
 

kg.legat0

Lifer
Sep 6, 2019
1,066
10,896
Southwestern PA
Definitely not a perfect match ...but this thread made me think that STG really needs to bring back Orlik Dark Strong Kentucky -- definitely not a 'match' for Dark Twist (which is lovely), but it has scratched a similar itch for me at times.
 

ReformedPiper

Lurker
Dec 28, 2021
13
37
Victoria, TX
not a twist or coin cut, but as i sit here smoking some C&D folkore that is starting to get some age on it.. it is very satisfying, and not too unlike my beloved aged Stockton and Dark Twist... not the same, but.. if you like those, try this.

Can you get Folklore still? I thought that was a special release.

There is nothing like them, excepting other Mac Baren products. If you like them, buy now!

Yeah, that's the conclusion I'm coming to. I so wish I was able to stock up right now. It seems the times and my finances aren't in alignment. I was looking for something I can start smoking moving forward. Just. Need. More. Time...
 
  • Like
Reactions: seanv

Sigmund

Lifer
Sep 17, 2023
3,515
34,575
France
You US guys who love KY ought to grab a pound of whole leaf and experiment. You have so many blends avaliable (still) that something pretty darn tasty could be mixed up at home. Its around 20 bucks a pound and that stuff is so potent it would make a bucket of tobacco once mixed.

Its not rocket science to ammend a currently made blend. It would be fun to see more home recipies on the forum. Maybe after this closure it will become more active
 

ReformedPiper

Lurker
Dec 28, 2021
13
37
Victoria, TX
You US guys who love KY ought to grab a pound of whole leaf and experiment. You have so many blends avaliable (still) that something pretty darn tasty could be mixed up at home. Its around 20 bucks a pound and that stuff is so potent it would make a bucket of tobacco once mixed.

Its not rocket science to ammend a currently made blend. It would be fun to see more home recipies on the forum. Maybe after this closure it will become more active

This is definitely something I'd love to try. But Mac Baren just has a way with how they make that Dark Twist and Stockton. They knew what they were doing. 🤤
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pipke and Sigmund