I literally flipped a coin on this one. Turns out my vote is for #1.
pipingfool Can't Leave Sep 29, 2016 369 1,475 Seattle, WA Feb 10, 2023 #21 I literally flipped a coin on this one. Turns out my vote is for #1. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Tar Wheel Lifer May 23, 2020 1,463 21,192 Winston-Salem, North Carolina Feb 10, 2023 #22 #1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
FurCoat Lifer Sep 21, 2020 8,764 78,500 North Carolina Feb 10, 2023 #23 #1!!!! #1!!! Fukin ay #1. Like @TheIronMonkey said, there is an elegance to that pipe. Reactions: SBC and alaskanpiper
Latakia Dave Lifer Mar 4, 2021 1,666 20,964 Shenandoah Vally Virginia Feb 10, 2023 #24 I’m going with #2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
hoosierpipeguy Lifer Jan 28, 2018 12,952 134,571 66 Sarasota, FL Feb 10, 2023 #25 1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
PA Piper Mike Lifer Oct 3, 2021 1,093 5,067 Southeastern PA Feb 10, 2023 #26 Def no. 1 on this. As for 2, I'm a sucker for bamboo, but as others have said, it just doesn't mesh well in this case. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Def no. 1 on this. As for 2, I'm a sucker for bamboo, but as others have said, it just doesn't mesh well in this case.
Coreios Lifer Sep 23, 2022 1,614 2,676 41 United States Of America Feb 10, 2023 #27 2 for me. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Sjmiller CPG (sjmiller) May 8, 2015 544 1,010 56 Morgan County, Tennessee Feb 10, 2023 #29 No. 1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
scloyd Lifer May 23, 2018 5,938 12,031 Feb 10, 2023 #31 #1 I like the cocobolo wood shank and the smooth rim. Reactions: alaskanpiper
O OzPiper Lifer Nov 30, 2020 5,756 30,560 71 Sydney, Australia Feb 10, 2023 #33 Pipe #1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
Briar Tuck Lifer Nov 29, 2022 1,109 5,737 Oregon coast Feb 10, 2023 #34 As much as I love the bamboo, I have to go with #1. Reactions: canucklehead and alaskanpiper
Toast Part of the Furniture Now Feb 15, 2021 659 1,311 UK Feb 10, 2023 #35 Two, for me. Reactions: alaskanpiper
E Englomatic Lurker Jun 18, 2020 38 276 56 Central Virginia Feb 10, 2023 #36 #1. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Sidehatch Part of the Furniture Now Jan 30, 2022 567 10,061 Colorado Feb 10, 2023 #37 1 it is. Finding I’m drawing more to darker colors in these matchups Reactions: alaskanpiper
jpmcwjr Moderator Staff member May 12, 2015 24,565 27,064 Carmel Valley, CA Feb 10, 2023 #38 One in for the win. Reactions: alaskanpiper
V virginiapiper Starting to Get Obsessed Jun 27, 2013 223 1,081 Virginia Feb 10, 2023 #39 #1 Reactions: alaskanpiper