#1
CoffeeAndBourbon Lifer Jun 18, 2020 3,798 13,538 Wilmington, NC Feb 6, 2023 #21 #1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
TheIronMonkey Lifer Dec 3, 2021 4,791 40,288 Pennsylvania & New York Feb 6, 2023 #22 Number one is really interesting. It gets my vote. While two is nicely done, it seems pedestrian by comparison. Reactions: canucklehead, alaskanpiper and CoffeeAndBourbon
Number one is really interesting. It gets my vote. While two is nicely done, it seems pedestrian by comparison.
pipingfool Can't Leave Sep 29, 2016 369 1,475 Seattle, WA Feb 6, 2023 #23 Tough one. But #1 gets my vote. Reactions: alaskanpiper
jpmcwjr Moderator Staff member May 12, 2015 24,565 27,065 Carmel Valley, CA Feb 6, 2023 #24 One. Though a bit overwrought for my taste, Reactions: CoffeeAndBourbon and alaskanpiper
F fireground_piper Lifer Jan 30, 2020 1,850 6,086 New Jersey Feb 6, 2023 #25 2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
scloyd Lifer May 23, 2018 5,938 12,031 Feb 6, 2023 #27 #2...no bamboo. Reactions: alaskanpiper and fireground_piper
Briar Tuck Lifer Nov 29, 2022 1,109 5,737 Oregon coast Feb 6, 2023 #28 Another really tough call. I love the simple grace and refinement of number two, but I also love the uniqueness of number one. The bamboo again sways my decision and I vote for number one. Reactions: canucklehead and alaskanpiper
Another really tough call. I love the simple grace and refinement of number two, but I also love the uniqueness of number one. The bamboo again sways my decision and I vote for number one.
LotusEater Lifer Apr 16, 2021 4,083 55,924 Kansas City Missouri Feb 6, 2023 #29 I wish these two hadn’t been matched against each other. Reactions: alaskanpiper and SBC
E Englomatic Lurker Jun 18, 2020 38 276 56 Central Virginia Feb 6, 2023 #30 #1 Reactions: alaskanpiper
agnosticpipe Lifer Nov 3, 2013 3,332 3,412 In the sticks in Mississippi Feb 6, 2023 #31 Gonna have to go with #2. Reactions: alaskanpiper
FurCoat Lifer Sep 21, 2020 8,764 78,501 North Carolina Feb 6, 2023 #32 #1 Wow that's pretty Reactions: alaskanpiper
SBC Lifer Oct 6, 2021 1,518 7,240 NE Wisconsin Feb 6, 2023 #33 #1 deserves some kind of prize in this tourny -- it is brilliant in its unique idiom -- but I'm a traditionalist, so in a cutty contest I'm going with #2. But seriously #1 is very special for somebody. Just not for me. Reactions: alaskanpiper
#1 deserves some kind of prize in this tourny -- it is brilliant in its unique idiom -- but I'm a traditionalist, so in a cutty contest I'm going with #2. But seriously #1 is very special for somebody. Just not for me.
bluegrassbrian Your Mom's Favorite Pipe Smoker Aug 27, 2016 5,970 51,327 41 Louisville Feb 6, 2023 #35 Oh what the hell.. I'll say ONE Reactions: alaskanpiper
MCJ Can't Leave May 22, 2022 424 3,615 NW Connecticut Feb 6, 2023 #36 Number 2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
BCF Part of the Furniture Now Dec 23, 2022 666 10,227 Pennsylvania Feb 6, 2023 #37 2 Reactions: alaskanpiper
cshubhra Lifer May 11, 2017 10,958 118,130 NJ,USA,Earth,Sol,MilkyWay,Virgo SC, Laniakea SC, Feb 6, 2023 #38 The first pipe has a very unique blast. It looks like it is made of Strawberrywood. The second pipe is very conservative (Yet does not have the foot) Reminds me of Dunhill Shell Finish. #1 Reactions: alaskanpiper, LotusEater and canucklehead
The first pipe has a very unique blast. It looks like it is made of Strawberrywood. The second pipe is very conservative (Yet does not have the foot) Reminds me of Dunhill Shell Finish. #1
kcghost Lifer May 6, 2011 13,140 21,408 77 Olathe, Kansas Feb 6, 2023 #39 I prefer #2. Reactions: alaskanpiper
Toast Part of the Furniture Now Feb 15, 2021 659 1,312 UK Feb 6, 2023 #40 One by a country mile. That's a stunner! Reactions: alaskanpiper