Cutty Madness. Match 1.

[alaskanpiper]

Seems like to top pipe is the winner. No contest. You may as well tell us who carved it, since the bottom one is obvious anyway. They're both beautiful and this is a cruel exercise and you are an incorrigible enabler.

Nothing can be revealed until the end, sir! For the winning pipe, albeit pretty obviously the first one at this point, will have to face off against another winner in round 2! And as it looks now possibly round 3 and finals in this case!

 

[Winnipeger]

Nothing can be revealed until the end, sir! For the winning pipe, albeit pretty obviously the first one at this point, will have to face off against another winner in round 2! And as it looks now possibly round 3 and finals in this case!

You'll have tell us in the end all that really matters: which one is the best smoker.

 

[Blue ridge smoke]

Easy win for the first pipe.

 

[cosmicfolklore]

#1, and I think I can guess both carvers.
Wow, so you own all of these? Nice…

 

[Ahi Ka]

#1, and I think I can guess both carvers.
Wow, so you own all of these? Nice…

Nah he just commissioned them, got the pics for the competition and then bailed

 

[kcghost]

I like the first pipe.

 

[HawkeyeLinus]

The first one!

If the other had been "orgasmically" themed . . . . .

 

[PipesRock]

1st one for reasons already stated. Seems that despite craggy... ball sack... commentary it seems to be holding it's own in the rankings too.

 

[alaskanpiper]

You'll have tell us in the end all that really matters: which one is the best smoker.

Haha that will take a bit to determine!

 

[alaskanpiper]

#1, and I think I can guess both carvers.
Wow, so you own all of these? Nice…

For the moment at least! I may sell some of them down the road a bit, but currently they are all in hand.

 

[brian64]

Nothing can be revealed until the end, sir! For the winning pipe, albeit pretty obviously the first one at this point, will have to face off against another winner in round 2! And as it looks now possibly round 3 and finals in this case!

You started this thing right out of the gate with a real humdinger...I'll be surprised if there are any of the 16 I like more than #1 here.

EDIT: one of the many things I like about it that I'm not sure anyone else has mentioned, it does have an obligatory cutty cant to it, but it's almost imperceptible. Just how I would want it if I commissioned one.

 

[ron123]

#1, and I think I can guess both carvers.

Same vote and I think I got em both too ;-)

 

[virginiapiper]

#1 what an interesting take on the curry concept!

 

[Ahi Ka]

Man I love predictive text

 

[SBC]

Ebay sees a sudden surge in "cutty pipe" queries...

Ebay data guy calls his financial guy: "Move all my stock into something called 'cutty pipes'...I don't know what they are yet but as of Feb. 1 they're the next big thing..."

 

[alaskanpiper]

You started this thing right out of the gate with a real humdinger...I'll be surprised if there are any of the 16 I like more than #1 here.

EDIT: one of the many things I like about it that I'm not sure anyone else has mentioned, it does have an obligatory cutty cant to it, but it's almost imperceptible. Just how I would want it if I commissioned one.

As they rolled in over the months I kept thinking the same thing, but was continually surprised.

 

[Sidehatch]

I vote #2 but it’s a formality at this time. Cool idea and look forward to seeing other matchups

 

[upnorth1]

First one!

 

[LotusEater]

As they rolled in over the months I kept thinking the same thing, but was continually surprised.

Don’t tell us which one )yet) but do you know which of the 16 is your favorite?

 

[BlueRidge]

#1