Cobblestone Black Coffee

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

48 Fresh Nørding Pipes
3 Fresh Chris Asteriou Pipes
New Cigars
32 Fresh Moonshine Pipes
2 Fresh Lv Zelong Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

BurleyVonPuffington

Starting to Get Obsessed
Feb 26, 2021
214
3,421
This is more of a short and sweet several notes and isn't intended to remotely be a full review, but I couldn't find a mention here, and I certainly haven't seen any experienced smoker weigh in on this one. As you may know, Cobblestone Cafe' is a Sutliffe brand, so it's future may be in question, but I doubt this will be in high demand on the secondary market. The pluses are as always, Sutliffe sourced high quality gold and black cavendish; it smokes like a 19th century train; they infused this blend with real Brazilian coffee; and no sugary goop to be found whatsoever.

So the negative? You can't smoke it WITH black coffee, unless you truly do love the bitterness that goes with all coffees roasted enough to be black when brewed. Black coffee, especially the good stuff, does have other flavors, though, like a tasty bitter ale with intense floral notes. But this tobacco blend just tastes bitter. Smoke it slow, smoke it fast, smoke it in any pipe, and it's just bitter. Frankly, some of us, because we like black coffee and ales, like some bitter in moderation, along with other tastes that make bitter a fine flavor in a given context. But not when it's JUST bitter. And when you take the ordinary premium coffee and smoke this with it for breakfast? The intensity of the "bitter" is nigh overwhelming. Imagine your favorite black coffee suddenly being TWICE as bitter. That was my experience.

As always, YMMV, but my advice would be to pair the smoke with a caramel latte' to tone down the "candy" factor of the coffee, not black coffee.Cobblestone Black Coffee.JPEG
 

BurleyVonPuffington

Starting to Get Obsessed
Feb 26, 2021
214
3,421
I got nothing but honey and molasses from that one, no bitterness.
Thanks for reporting with your experience. Did you smoke it while drinking black coffee? And did you get any coffee taste beyond the honey and bitterness?

All I can say is it was cellared for years, and that usually helps, but sometimes makes things worse, and that I'll give it a try tomorrow without coffee, see what I taste, and report back. While only a modest fan of aromatics, I usually like all of Sutliff's stuff, and get the sweet stuff on literally every other single aromatic blend of theirs I've tried. So frankly this was totally oddball for me.
 

BurleyVonPuffington

Starting to Get Obsessed
Feb 26, 2021
214
3,421
That's the only coffee that I drink. You may have gotten it too hot smoking it.
As promised, I did a follow-up with no coffee, then adding coffee late during the bowl for a swallow or two for comparision. I largely agree with your assessment if I'm not drinking coffee. Maybe one of the best aromatics I've ever had. Sweet but not as much as usual, sour close on the heels of sweet, and only a very slight bitterness, which I like, underlying it all. VERY pleasant. 75% of the way through, enjoying and smoking, I added a sip or two of Peet's Major Dickason's, and it all immediately went to hell. Just this one black coffee blend when I add black coffee apparently. Went away when I rinsed out my mouth and went back to my pipe.

Never had it happen in decades of both pipe and cigar smoking, and this bitterness is distinct from the coffee's own bitterness, or when you overheat a cigar or pipe, which I call getting "skunky". Love my black coffee and a pipe or cigar, but not this one. Glad I found out, though, so I can just enjoy it by itself.

I appreciate your sharing your different experience with it, or it might have literally been the first tin of tobacco I tossed in the trash, when it's very enjoyable.
 

NookersTheCat

Can't Leave
Sep 10, 2020
360
1,286
NEPA
I recently tried the Walnut Maple Pie and found the same thing. Sure there was some aromatic there (I'm a big aromatic fan so I'm not someone who's gonna complain about an aromatic being an aromatic lol) but mostly just bitterness. In fact, it was a bitterness I'd never really experienced before... it clang to my tongue even well after I'd finished what I could of the bowl (about 3/4's, and I'm not adverse to throwing a bowl out before that so I really tried).

I don't remember what I was drinking with it but generally always some type of Sam Adams.
I'd say maybe I just got a bad batch but if I'm experiencing the same phenomenon on a different blend from a different line made in different years (just purchased last month) then something tells me (as you alluded to) this aromatic line will not be widely missed. Bittersweet for me... I really wanted to enjoy this one but I'm also glad that's far less tobacco I now have to track down and hoard 😅
 
  • Like
Reactions: BurleyVonPuffington