Civil War Period Briar Pipe

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

homeguard95

Starting to Get Obsessed
Mar 18, 2014
206
0
While I like the pipe I have to agree with jitterbugdude, the most common pipe in that time was clay they were cheap to make and cheap to buy, and even if a soldier could afford that nice of a pipe I would bet that it stayed at the house waiting on him to come back if nothing else to keep it from being lost,broke, or stolen.

 

virginiacob

Can't Leave
Dec 30, 2013
450
7
ejames -- The shank is made of black walnut. The band between the shank and the bit is German silver and the bit itself is Vulcanite.
twanghang -- I try to stick with straight Virginia blends when smoking at Civil War events. Red burley did exist during the period but white burley (initially discovered as a mutation) wasn't discovered until a few years after the war.
jitterbugdude and homeguard95 -- I have to beg to differ with you re: briar and cob pipes not being period correct for the Civil War period. By the mid-1850s, briar had quickly gained popularity in Europe as well as here in the States. First, I would agree with you that briar pipes would have been less common among enlisted men as these pipes would have been expensive compared to clays, but there is plenty of photo evidence of officers during the Civil War smoking briar pipes (photos do exist of some privates (probably from more well-to-do families) smoking briar pipes as well). It would, however, have been easy for a Confederate soldier, for instance, to acquire such a pipe as a battlefield pickup taken from a dead or captured Union officer or from a captured baggage train. There's even evidence that briar pipes were being smuggled into the Confederacy by blockade runners from Europe as a "luxury" item to increase their profit margins on their cargo. I portray a 1st Lt. in my reenacting unit, so as an officer the briar pipe would certainly have been accessible for my rank and pay. Re: cobs, the argument that cob pipes were invented after the Civil War is inaccurate. There is plenty of evidence to support the use of cob pipes before and during the Civil War. Most folks get confused by the 1869 date which is the date credited to when Henry Tibbe began commercially producing the corn cob pipe, however, homemade cob pipes did exist prior to 1869. First, in the Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, set in the 1840s, Mark Twain has Huck smoking a cob pipe. It's doubtful that Twain would have made the mistake of using a cob pipe in his novel if it didn't exist during the time period of his novel. Second, Confederate President Jefferson Davis in his memoirs noted that cob pipes were commonly smoked on his antebellum plantation. Also, in his September 1863 diary entry, a soldier in the 37th Indiana Regiment commented that his regiment had encountered a field of corn and noted that while the corn was too green to eat, it did make for some nice pipes to replace their "fragile clays" that kept breaking. I firmly believe that cob pipes were a common utilitarian tobacco pipe of the period that could easily be made with a simple pocketknife and once the cob was no longer usable it was simply discarded with no fanfare. Most rural folks of this era were very self-sufficient and if they could make something without having to purchase it they would do so. Being organic, cob pipes would have quickly deteriorated and therefore leave little archaeological evidence of their existence unlike inorganic clay pipes. With all that said, white clay pipes and reed stem clay pipes (often referred to as trade pipes) would have been extremely common during the Civil War among enlisted men and these pipes are often found at archaeological excavations of both Union and Confederate campsites. I should also note that while chewing tobacco was a common way of enjoying tobacco during the period, pipe smoking was just as common if not more so. Cigars also gained tremendous popularity during the the war but were rather expensive and so they tended to be more commonly smoked by officers rather than enlisted men.

 

homeguard95

Starting to Get Obsessed
Mar 18, 2014
206
0
virginiacob I didn't mean for what I said to sound like I was calling you out in history, because I wasn't, I was simply saying that for enlisted men clay pipes would've been more common in the field than briar, I know if I had a pipe like that and I was heading off to war that pipe would be under my floorboards until I got back to guard it. :mrgreen: I agree with you one hundred percent when it comes to corn cob pipes in the civil war, and the fact that you portray a 1st.Lieutenant makes much more sense as to why you would carry such a pipe.

 

virginiacob

Can't Leave
Dec 30, 2013
450
7
homeguard,
No worries. I didn't mean to get long-winded with my response or give the impression that I had gotten my feathers ruffled. I just wanted to throw in my 2 cents as to the period correctness of briar and cob pipes based upon my own research. One of the great things that I've found about researching the Civil War over the years is that despite all you think you know, there's always more information to be uncovered and new incites to be discovered. I do agree with you that when it comes to the pipe commonly smoked by the enlisted man in both armies, the clay pipe would certainly have been the most common. I have a reed stem clay pipe that I also use from time to time when I'm not portraying an officer at an event.

 

homeguard95

Starting to Get Obsessed
Mar 18, 2014
206
0
I have a reed stem clay pipe also but I'm afraid to smoke mine for fear of dropping it. :D I appreciate what people like yourself do with the reenacting, it was a living history show that really sucked me in to History.

 

virginiacob

Can't Leave
Dec 30, 2013
450
7
homeguard,
My reed stem clay pipe is actually a reproduction. Like you, I'd be a little nervous smoking an original as it is too easy for things to get lost out in the field or broken. I'll probably be smoking it in a couple of weeks as I'm planning to attend a living history encampment for the Gettysburg National Battlefield Park and for that one I'll be portraying a Confederate private.

 

homeguard95

Starting to Get Obsessed
Mar 18, 2014
206
0
Yeah I bought it with the intention of smoking it but so far it's been nothing more than a neat little relic to look at.

 

bookn3rd5

Starting to Get Obsessed
Nov 29, 2012
177
1
As a social studies/history teacher, I love this thread and the discussion it has inspired! So cool - congrats on that beauty of a pipe!

 

benrapaport

Lurker
Apr 19, 2011
20
16
To all you Civil War reenactors and to those who simply relish seeing pipes carved by soldiers of the American Civil War, take note. As the sesquicentennial of this war comes to a close next year, there is a new book to add to the trove of non-fiction literature about this war. I just finished Tobacco and Smoking Among The Blue and Gray. The Illustrated History of an American Folk-Art Curiosity: The Civil War Soldier's Tobacco Pipe. It's a hard-cover book with DJ, some 300 pages, fully illustrated in color with about 150 images of tobacco pipes from this war, along with an account of what and how they smoked, and much more. It is being published as a limited edition by Briar Books Press (Gary Schrier), and will be available in December, just in time to tuck under your holiday tree.
Ben Rapaport

 

phred

Lifer
Dec 11, 2012
1,754
5
Very cool pipe! And a good history lesson, as well.
Definitely looking forward to Mr. Rapaport's book - this has been a most educational thread.

 

maxpeters

Can't Leave
Jan 4, 2010
439
22
150 years is still too short a time to forget what those "damn yankee invaders" did to the South, so yeah, it's still a sore topic. And some folk will tell you it's not over yet. Memories have a way of lasting a long long time. But this is a pipe forum, so I will not say another word about that. But yes, beautiful pipe.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.