Cigars were also my first love and I still enjoy one every now and again. It is funny when I first got into pipes because I was a big maduro fan...big, bold, smack you in face flavors and body. Give me a strong cup o' joe or a whiskey and a cigar and life was good. The pipe seemed timid at first, even with Latakia, Perique, and other strong tobaccos. Now that I am actually understanding HOW to smoke a pipe (a cigar you pretty much figure out your first time)I am getting different nuances and notes that I wasn't getting from cigars. I smoked one over the weekend and while it was quite enjoyable I noticed how little work went into it. Yes I had to unwrap it, cut it, get a good light and ensure the cap end was still intact, but after that it was just puff time, to whatever cadence I wanted. I think both are enjoyable and each has their own ritual, but have been leaning HEAVY toward the pipe in the last 7 months.