I especially like the smooth pipe for its subtle nuanced interpretation of the shape, the slender but not fragile shank, and the tapered bowl, that still says more billiard than brandy to me. The bright light band is another nice touch, just short of being jarring. He really has control of his medium and does wonders with decisive but understated design. I can never keep my Canadians, Liverpools, and Lumberman straight, but this is a beauty by any name. The bamboo shank pipe is also exquisite, but the smooth pipe stole the show for me.