Cellaring- How Long is too Long?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

12 Fresh Erik Stokkebye 4th Generation Pipes
3 Fresh Emiliano Pipes
2 Fresh Sabina Santos Pipes
6 Fresh Claudio Cavicchi Pipes
3 Fresh Mike Sebastian Bay Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

rmpeeps

Lifer
Oct 17, 2017
1,141
1,833
San Antonio, TX
So I started smoking a pipe about 2 months ago after being a long time cigarette smoker. It's definitely something I'll be doing for a very long time. I have a few pounds safely cellared away at this point, and as of now it's all Va's and VaPers. I've read dozens of forums and articles on the subject but there's one thing I can't find any information on- will the tobacco eventually be so old it just goes bad even if properly stored? I'm currently 29 years old and have some decent discretionary funds to build up a pretty good sized cellar relatively quickly. At 29 I (hopefully) have many many more years of smoking, but if I cellar up a lifetime supply or close to a lifetime supply within the next let's say 2-4 years would that tobacco even be good by the time I'm 75 in 40+ years? I plan on also getting more kinds other than Va's and VaPers (no aromatics for me, for now anyways)
You’re young. Get what you want now, and buy up our cellars as we old folks die.
 
Mar 1, 2014
3,657
4,952
So I started smoking a pipe about 2 months ago after being a long time cigarette smoker. It's definitely something I'll be doing for a very long time. I have a few pounds safely cellared away at this point, and as of now it's all Va's and VaPers. I've read dozens of forums and articles on the subject but there's one thing I can't find any information on- will the tobacco eventually be so old it just goes bad even if properly stored? I'm currently 29 years old and have some decent discretionary funds to build up a pretty good sized cellar relatively quickly. At 29 I (hopefully) have many many more years of smoking, but if I cellar up a lifetime supply or close to a lifetime supply within the next let's say 2-4 years would that tobacco even be good by the time I'm 75 in 40+ years? I plan on also getting more kinds other than Va's and VaPers (no aromatics for me, for now anyways)
I have a few jars of 10 year old tobacco now but I keep buying new stuff at a pace where I never dip into the old so I can't say what the effect really is.
What I've heard most commonly is Latakia loses flavor fastest.
Anything laced with Perique will probably taste good forever.
 
Mar 1, 2014
3,657
4,952
Dunhill stopped blending decades ago.

McClelland, on the other hand…

I recently found a jar of Rose of Latakia from 2013. I was really looking forward to a flashback smoke of McC wonderfullness. Instead, I found that the Latakia had faded, and the resulting bowl was unremarkable. Not bad, mind you, but nothing out of the ordinary.

View attachment 240268
What was the moisture content?
Whenever I crack open a half empty old tin, the difference between dry Latakia and wet is night and day.
 

seaweed

Might Stick Around
Aug 2, 2023
71
164
Maine
I’m only a bit older at 34, and I’ve had the same thoughts. My plan is to cellar 15-20 years worth (luckily I really only like VAs and VAPers), then replace as I smoke. I don’t think most blends will hold up strongly past 20 years based on what I’ve read, so I don’t see the need to cellar beyond that.

I’m still concerned about tobacco being all but banned by the time I’m an old codger, so I plan to experiment with home blending and growing. I’m looking into home blending now, and will try growing in a few years when my cellar is a little more complete and I have more time.
 
Aug 11, 2022
2,582
20,214
Cedar Rapids, IA
I’m only a bit older at 34, and I’ve had the same thoughts. My plan is to cellar 15-20 years worth (luckily I really only like VAs and VAPers), then replace as I smoke. I don’t think most blends will hold up strongly past 20 years based on what I’ve read, so I don’t see the need to cellar beyond that.
You never know -- I'm buying a wide variety of stuff in case I get bored down the road. ;)
 

tmcg81

Lifer
May 8, 2020
1,019
15,885
NJ
So I've been smoking a pipe for 4.5 years at this point. First six months, I bought small samples or single tins and tried probably a couple dozen blends. I saw all the online chatter about deeming regulations and all that, plus I started not that long after McClelland ceased production and the STG Dunhills disappeared. I knew that smoking a pipe was something I really enjoyed and I'm not really one of those dudes that has a million hobbies taking up his time and money. I figured I could probably spend a little money on some tobacco for a rainy day. Then my landlord sold my house from under me, and my wife and I were given 3 weeks notice to vacate a home we'd lived in for 7 or 8 years, and we had to be out like two days before Christmas. We couldn't find a place that fast and ended up moving into my parents place to regroup and look for a new pad. Then Covid happened. I worked every single day and had more money than I'd ever seen in my life (good paycheck, no rent or household bills). I decided to start cellaring. I had the time, money, and space. I built up a cellar that will probably last me the next 15 years. But I rushed into it. I was smoking a ton of English blends at the time. So I bought a ton of English blends. Now, a tin of Westminster will last a couple months, not the couple weeks it used to. I wish I would have taken some more time to figure out what I liked, instead of rushing into buying a shitload of English blends. Luckily, I figured out I was a burley guy towards the end of that buying spree and stocked up on some of my favorites. I'm good for a while now, but I'd be better if I thought it out more.
 

litup

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 16, 2015
761
2,331
Sacramento, CA
I haven't seen anyone mention this yet but, as others have noted, I might slow down the buying a little bit too. Since you're fairly new to pipe smoking, there's a very high chance that your tastes will change over time. And if they do, what do you do with a lifetime supply of tobaccos that you no longer like to smoke? I'd keep trying new blends and when you find some that you like a lot, buy some of that for cellaring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThermionicScott

pipingfool

Can't Leave
Sep 29, 2016
369
1,479
Seattle, WA
I would think that just about any blend that has been sitting in a tin/jar/Mylar for 40+ years is going to have deteriorated to some degree. There are exceptions to every rule, but if it were me, I would not shoot for that length of aging.

Here is what I do...

I usually buy 5-10 tins at a time or 1-2 pounds of bulk at a time of blends that I have tried and know I like, or blends that are from blenders I like and have components that I know that I like. I'll usually read the reviews of them (really only @JimInks or @pipestud on tobaccoreviews.com; I tend to trust their palates) to get a sense of the overall flavors that I know I like.

I'll usually open a tin fresh and smoke a bit it to get a feel for it if it's a blend I've never tried. 90% of the time I have chosen wisely. The ones that I don't necessarily care for go into a jar or Mylar and I'll wait and try it again in a few months to a year. Some blends do improve for my tastes after a little time.

If it's a blend I have already tried, I generally just put them in cellar and date them.

I'll usually open another tin in a couple of years to see how it's doing and if it is aging favorably.

The rest sit in the cellar until I'm ready to pop them open. But I can tell you that I probably will not let any of my blends reach 30yrs old. They will probably be consumed within the 10-20 year mark, and most by the 7-9 year mark.

Maybe a tin or two here and there that I will keep around that long just so I can say I've tried tobacco that old, but we'll see.

My cellar contains mostly Virginia and Va/Pers, but I do have a decent amount of English Blends that have aged very nicely over the past several years. 6 year old GL Pease Quiet Nights is quite the experience in my opinion.

Good luck and keep us posted on how your cellar progresses!
 

HalfMadHatter

Lurker
Jun 21, 2023
33
48
30
Ohio
I’m only a bit older at 34, and I’ve had the same thoughts. My plan is to cellar 15-20 years worth (luckily I really only like VAs and VAPers), then replace as I smoke. I don’t think most blends will hold up strongly past 20 years based on what I’ve read, so I don’t see the need to cellar beyond that.

I’m still concerned about tobacco being all but banned by the time I’m an old codger, so I plan to experiment with home blending and growing. I’m looking into home blending now, and will try growing in a few years when my cellar is a little more complete and I have more time.
Yeah I plan on growing my own eventually too. Right now I'm living on the road though so not really an option. Or I'd be starting now
 

vosBghos

Lifer
May 7, 2022
1,630
3,581
Idaho
I've been smoking a 25 year old F&T Golden Mixture that I got for $35 bucks and all I can say is DAM it feels good to be a gangster. Dont even know who was producing it then. But if there is a blend you really really like buy an already aged tin and if it's good buy it by the sleeve and stock up. I only have a handful of blends ( a couple of each genre) that I stock up on but no time like the present.
 
Aug 11, 2022
2,582
20,214
Cedar Rapids, IA
But I rushed into it. I was smoking a ton of English blends at the time. So I bought a ton of English blends. Now, a tin of Westminster will last a couple months, not the couple weeks it used to. I wish I would have taken some more time to figure out what I liked, instead of rushing into buying a shitload of English blends.,. I'm good for a while now, but I'd be better if I thought it out more.
I bet lots of members are in that boat. English blends like Nightcap were the first that I bought multiples at a time, too.
 

andrew

Lifer
Feb 13, 2013
3,059
428
The thing is too if you open an old tin or jar smoke it, don't have a bowl then put it away, it degrades pretty fast from what I hear
 

KingcobraJFS

Lurker
Sep 22, 2021
36
74
The thing is too if you open an old tin or jar smoke it, don't have a bowl then put it away, it degrades pretty fast from what I hear
I think this is way overexaggerated. I stock up heavily on my favorite blends and have a ton of jarred blends. I open them to have bowls now and then and they've done well for years now. They only start to deteriorate when they are mostly empty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: seaweed