Had a chance to fire up my 55 for the first time last night with some Capstan Blue. I am officially a Castello convert! Wow! Not sure I can put to words what made this such a great smoker -- it just was.
Only drawback was I over loaded the pipe, so it did not burn as well as it probably would have - first time loading that pipe and first time with capstan blue as well. I started with 1.5 flakes and should have just done one, or maybe even 3/4 of a flake. Those flakes are rather thick. Despite having too much tobacco in there, it still burned well (much better than I think any of my other pipes would have done with my mistake. Turned into about a 3 hour smoke, cool and dry the whole way through. Never even a hint of over-heating, which is something I seem to struggle with at times with other pipes.
Contrast that to the new Peterson silver spigot system pipe I purchased a few months ago. After about 10 or 15 bowls it is just now finally breaking in to the point of being a decent smoker. Those first 7 bowls for so were an exercise in frustration. I am fighting an urge to sell all of my other pipes to fund the purchase of a couple more Castellos and being done with it.
As to the Capstan blue, this is my first foray into Virginia Flake. I have mostly smoked mild aros and English blends. I really liked it. I'm thinking Virginia Flakes will become a part of my regular rotation. However, it seemed that the Capstan blue has a fairly strong nic hit. Compared to cigars, it has been rare for me to feel any nicotine effect, but man it hit me hard last night. Maybe it was more of the 3 hours vs a higher nicotine content?
Anyway, for me the Castello hype is not hype anymore. I don't understand or see what makes the pipe that much better than my other pipes, but there is a difference.