Cast away with one choice.Only one!!

[redpanda]

That is exactly the reason I started this post. How interesting. Half of the blends mentioned so far I have not even heard of. Keep it coming !

 

[tarheel1]

Penzance is my favorite. Has been since 2005.

 

[clickklick]

McClelland Balkan beauty

 

[shawnofthedead]

MCC Balkan Blue

 

[beezer]

Hmm...toughie. I'd have to go with S.G.'s Full Virginia Flake (FVF). I figure since virginia's get better with age the thought of being stranded on an island indefinitely would be psychologically easier to cope with if I knew that over time my tobacco would get better and better. If I hit the 10 year mark on a deserted island I'd like to celebrate with a supremely aged virginia rather than a latakia-heavy blend that was past its prime. That would be depressing.

 

[pipeboy122]

Samuel Gawith FVF

 

[elpfeife]

I am tempted to say Wessex Brigade Campaign DF, but I'd go with Brigham's Hudson Bay.

 

[mso489]

C&D Billy Budd, but I sure would dream of fifty or sixty others I enjoy a lot. Nat Sherman 536, Nightcap, PC Chestnut, Old Joe Krantz, Old Dark Fired ....

 

[skraps]

C&D Night Train.

 

[jpmcwjr]

GL Pease Westminister. This woman on this particular island won't want to be with a man who smokes a baccy largely to please her! Bring on the Lat!

 

[andrew]

I would probably go with El Ricon de la Pipa #1, it's my daily smoke, never lets me down, it has turkish izmir, really high quality Va's (I'm pretty sure one of them is SG Kendal flake) burley, unsweetened cavendish and just a hint of lat. It never seems to get boring for me.

 

[prairiedruid]

Been on a 3 Oaks Syrian kick lately but if I'll be there forever MM 965 will age better.

 

[tobyducote]

Squadron Leader

 

[cfreud]

@Tarheel1 ... but would Penzance be available on the island?

 

[tslex]

Although there are other tobaccos I actually like better, if I had to smoke one and only one forever -- FMOTT.
(I.e., I like Penzance better than FMOTT, but wouldn't want an unrelenting diet of it.)

 

[drwatson]

HMMM That depends. Will his female that I'm stranded with be smoking my pipe too? 8O

 

[mso489]

Tobac-Manil Semois thick cut ... oops, this is my second post. My bad.

 

[maxx]

Today, it would be C&D Da Vinci.

 

[fadingdaylight]

Another vote for FVF here. If I could only have one. Perhaps ODF.

 

[delkhouri]

Tough call. I am going to say McCranie's Red Ribbon but I will probably change my mind in 10 minutes