Carter Hall Replacement Question

[stokesdale]

I'm making an order from Smoking Pipes large enough to get free shipping and was hoping to get a few pouches of Carter Hall. Every once in a while I get an urge to smoke some, but SP seems to be out of it. Does anyone know of a GOOD replacement for Carter Hall? It doesn't have to be an OTC, but it does have to be in stock at SP, and it needs to be like CH--i.e., a tobacco that's technically an aromatic, but not really like an aromatic because frankly, I don't like traditional aromatics, and have the same sort of taste profile...people who smoke it know what I mean so please only respond if you actually know what CH is like. I'm trying to get an order in by 4 pm today...(Dec 4). Thanks for the help in advance if anyone can.

 

[mso489]

I'm not sure if SP stocks it, but Sutliff's (and PC's) Chatham Manor is akin if not a match, and many prefer it. I keep some on hand. It is available in a baggie at PC, as well as a tub, but I think it is also offered in bulk, since that's how I got mine. Matches are always tricky in terms of how much they match, but Chatham Manor is a pleasing mild blend that you might like even if it doesn't strike you as Carter Hall's identical twin.

 

[lightmybriar]

I'm not sure if SP stocks it, but Sutliff's (and PC's) Chatham Manor is akin if not a match, and many prefer it. I keep some on hand. It is available in a baggie at PC, as well as a tub, but I think it is also offered in bulk, since that's how I got mine. Matches are always tricky in terms of how much they match, but Chatham Manor is a pleasing mild blend that you might like even if it doesn't strike you as Carter Hall's identical twin.

Mso is giving good guidance! I much prefer Chatham Manor and I think you’d like it too!

 

[stokesdale]

I'm not sure if SP stocks it, but Sutliff's (and PC's) Chatham Manor is akin if not a match, and many prefer it. I keep some on hand. It is available in a baggie at PC, as well as a tub, but I think it is also offered in bulk, since that's how I got mine. Matches are always tricky in terms of how much they match, but Chatham Manor is a pleasing mild blend that you might like even if it doesn't strike you as Carter Hall's identical twin.

Thanks MSO and lightmy! Just looked it up and everyone says exactly what you do...SP only has it in bulk, so I'll make the assumption its the same as the tub. Thanks again for letting me complete my order! Moderator, you can cut this thread off now if you like, although, if someone like me has been wondering the same thing, it might prove useful to leave it up for a while.

 

[Country Bladesmith]

Chatham Manor. Not exactly a match, but certainly in the same vein. And a good blend if you like easygoing blends like that.

 

[Chasing Embers]

Chatham Manor leaves a Saccharine aftertaste with me, go for C&D's Pegasus.

 

[stokesdale]

Chatham Manor. Not exactly a match, but certainly in the same vein. And a good blend if you like easygoing blends like that.

It's not often that I do; my go-to's are CRF, Interlude, BF #2, Crumble Kake Red, and JK Plug if that's any indication of my preferences, but every once in a while I would break out a pouch or two of Carter Hall because that sort of mellow sweetness on a burley was a nice alternative to the Kake Red in a virginia if that makes any sense.

 

[Country Bladesmith]

It's not often that I do; my go-to's are CRF, Interlude, BF #2, Crumble Kake Red, and JK Plug if that's any indication of my preferences, but every once in a while I would break out a pouch or two of Carter Hall because that sort of mellow sweetness on a burley was a nice alternative to the Kake Red in a virginia if that makes any sense.

Yeah, perfect sense. I’m the same way. Chatham Manor is one of those “change of pace” blends for me.

 

[stokesdale]

Chatham Manor leaves a Saccharine aftertaste with me, go for C&D's Pegasus.

I've tried that before, but it simply seems like a weaker version of BF #2 which I already smoke...I'm looking for something a little sweeter, but thanks for the rec anyway!

 

[Country Bladesmith]

Another one worth a mention is PS Cube Cut. Not a CH match, but it ticks some of the same boxes, profile-wise.

 

[stokesdale]

Another one worth a mention is PS Cube Cut. Not a CH match, but it ticks some of the same boxes, profile-wise.

Too late, lol. Just placed my order for 3 boxes of the Davidoff Churchill Belicoso's (since they are on sale) and the CM. With some pipe cleaners and a czech tool...my $95 is complete! Thanks all!

 

[Country Bladesmith]

Too late, lol. Just placed my order for 3 boxes of the Davidoff Churchill Belicoso's (since they are on sale) and the CM. With some pipe cleaners and a czech tool...my $95 is complete! Thanks all!

Not a bad haul. ?

 

[Magpiety]

Another one worth a mention is PS Cube Cut. Not a CH match, but it ticks some of the same boxes, profile-wise.

I wish I'd found this one earlier. It even has a pleasant natural sweetness on top.

 

[Tennessee Dave]

Country Squire Cherokee.

 

[highwaycobbery]

Try granger.