I agree it is sort of a conundrum, like experienced pipe smokers who already probably have (at least) quite a few pipes are the ones expert at shopping for basket pipes. Still, a new pipe smoker who has reviewed a lot of online retail sites, visited some pipe shops and pipe shows, and otherwise informed themselves, probably has a start on evaluating what they see. In fact, it is a sort of good exercise in developing an eye for pipe quality. If in doubt, don't buy a pipe. Or discuss a potential purchase with the proprietor, if he or she is someone you've come to trust. They might be able to find something similar, not in the basket, for just a little more, that would fill the bill. Part of basket shopping is knowing the shop and its owner, and how dependable they are. Some are gold mines of information, others know little.