Hey Jason,
It's ok, but I haven't thought about comparing the two.
As Dunhill 965 has yet to return to the States, I have to plead to the old adage...
"Distance makes the heart grow fonder."
965 is one of my all time favorites, so based on that I have to say that while the Sutliff Blend No. 5 is similar and good... it seems clumsy by comparison with memory.
The individual flavors seem chunkier than the smooth compilation of my recalled 965.
Did that make any sense.... I hope so.