Comparing flavor lineups I agree with both of you. Funny how COJ didn’t show up in the searches. There were a few reviews on there which helped. I will say, Payless C&P has is for $18.99 which is much cheaper than COJ. Payless also carry the Smoker Friendly Premium blends that BriarLee is raving about for $18.99 too. That works out to $25 a pound…cheaper than Sutliff or Lane bulks.
Smoker Friendly is also of Sutliff make according to Tobacco Reviews, so I suspect that these are another iteration of the same blends. They might be equivalent to Sutliff bulk blends, like how Smoker's Pride (made by Lane/STG) are equivalent to Lane bulk blends. The SP blends are worth trying as well, if you're looking for affordable aromatics.
Super Value blends are widely offered in pouch format, so if you want to try some or all of them, that might be the most affordable way to do so. SV Bourbon Whiskey (different from the Whiskey Cavendish) was my favorite of the lineup and the only one I really liked enough to buy a large bag.