Good article. I agree with the author in that pipe smoking today is much like pipe smoking back in the Victorian age - in a designated smoking room and not out in public. To me, this is not a bad thing. As far as OTC's go, there are only a few left standing - but most were not that good anyway. Commerce has changed, and we now buy our tobacco, mostly, off the internet. It's still thriving there. I'm not sure I miss the old B&M's that much. For many of us, I think that they've attained a mythic status that overshadows their reality. I just don't have any real experience with those mythic temples of tobacco, and the closest I ever got to one was the Tinderbox near Fort Meade, Maryland. It was pretty nice, but not all that. Most of the B&M's that I remember were tiny affairs, and not that much different that the cigar shops I occasionally go to today.
I love the Sutliff line of tobaccos. Not because they're outrageously good, but because they're priced like an OTC of yor, they offer as many varieties, and the tobacco is of better quality. Their Mapleton, Great Outdoors, R Blend, and CD Blend are great blends, and very reminiscent of the great OTC's of old. They're just not sold in grocery or drug stores, and I have to order them off line. but for about $7USD a tin they're great. Well-worth the few days that I have to wait for them to arrive.
Pipe buying is a whole different experience. I miss being able to handle them, but the reality is that I cn get a far better variety and at far better prices on line than at a B&M. If I stick to names that I am familiar with, in my case Sav, Pete, Falcon, and Dr. G then I'm good to go. I've never had a dog off the internet - but I have from the old B&M's.
I guess the more things change, the more they stay the same.