I don't think that there are many members who think that McClelland is/was not that good.
Did you just come onto the forums? Ha ha, I have always loved McClellands, but I have always thought of myself as part of a small minority. Every mention of McClelland always got shouted down for FVF or some other European bunk.
And, many of their blends all had the same production date on them, despite how many times I ordered them over the years. So, it was obvious that many, many of their Virginia blends just weren't popular. Tawny Flake and Aurora, I have ordered these many different times over the years, but always seem to get tins from the same canned batch date. So, either they ran millions in one day, or most likely, many of their blends were just sleepers for years. I think they were great, fantastic, the best even, but many, many, many have always found some problem with them.
Of course their limited run CC blends were always a hit. But, it wasn't till the rumors started that EVERYONE jumped on a band wagon and bought out everything. Even blends that had obviously sat on the shelf for years after their first run.