That was fun! Kaywoodies often had incredible grain. Sadly, they also usually had a daggum stinger and a terrible draw.
I love the flame grain on my old Kaywoodie apple, but I rarely smoke it because of the draw.
I agree with those who stated it above, this was a fun game. I know I guessed #1 being the more expensive pipe; however, I was sure you had taken a inferior photo of #2 to throw us off. Have said that, like I stated, I still went with #1. :?
I like the look of the first pipe more, but my guess would have been that the second one was the expensive one. I can see from the earlier post I would have been right. Both are great looking pipes, but I like the look and the stain more on the Kaywoodie.