19th., C Peterson Reading Pipe Button Repair
- Thread starter The Mitre
- Start date
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
Any other differences aside, George Dibos is recognized worldwide as one of the finest and most knowledgeable pipe restorers working in this day and age. Top collectors send their rarest and most precious museum quality pieces to George on which to work his magic. And one of the things that separates George from most other "restorers" is his deep knowledge of materials, how best to use them, and how to improve the structural integrity of the pipe he's working on, all with an invisible result.
So yes, he's much more than eminently qualified. He's pretty much the definition of eminently qualified.
.gif)
Even so, I don't like the result. It's expertly done, but the flow of the stem is not graceful and the stem feels too long. I'd like to see a picture of what this pipe originally looked like when it was in production, but based on similar pipes I've seen and owned, Mitre's approach, whatever technical faults there might or might not be, is closer to what the original might have been.
I'm glad that the guy is happy and that the pipe will be enjoyed. But the result just looks off to me.
Thanks Sagebrush52, out of all my misdemeanours I got one tiny ting right. I'll try harder next time. ATB Peter
Usually, the smart thing to do in this situation is throw yourself on the floor and beg the mercy of the court. It mystifies the people who will argue about it as if they were right.
I find that not taking criticism is a great way to not get better at something. Not that every critic is right, but to brush it off always is not a great way to improve. And that is one of those things that separates the greats from the good the constant search for improvement that little feeling that there might be a better way.
I would not be approaching my 57th year as a professional artist if I couldn't take criticism, even criticism that I disagreed with, and learn something from it. I may not be among the greats, but I'm still being offered opportunities at an age where almost all of my contemporaries have been shown the door.
Hey thanks for proving my point as well as another one I often make. You are one of the greats and like most of them you don't put yourself in that group.
another little thing i only am critical of artists who i think are good like exceptional. When people show me their art i sometimes have to add that caveat. Others are too good for that or get the ole making art is good for the soul no matter the end result. Another one i love is when the critism says you hit the mark. Example that song is horrible it makes me feel like i am going to be stabbed. That was the theme the feeling of attempted murder! Oh and thanks for your work i have paused a scene or two to get a nice long look.
still worth considering. Though it is a fact that sometimes it is easier to get someone to listen with tact, but sometimes a bullhorn is needed to get thru certain egos.
The threaded connector "killed" the curve. It had to be "long enough to be strong enough" (meaning sufficient surface engagement) to not pull out or twist over time, which meant there was no way to avoid having a straight section in a curved stem.
The choice was shorter than the original with a flowing curve, or original length with a jackknife bend.
There was no "C".
You prefer the curve because you're an artist and your brain is wired that way.
An historically minded person would probably prefer the length.
There is no unarguably correct choice.
I'm glad the baling-wire-and-duct-tape-multi-color-hack-fix-atrocity period of that pipe's life is in its rearview mirror, in any event.
I was referring to the pipe's state of affairs.
I think your road will continue to be rough.
- Status