Passed through Chambersburg two days ago. Definitely had to stop! A very nice shop, with friendly staff, and excellent selection. Wish that I had more time to enjoy the lounge, which looked nice.
If your R.I. blood allows it, there is a decent selection of non-tinned blends at James' Fine Cigars in Smithfield, R.I.. No tins, but a decent selection of bulks.
Thanks for sharing your experiences. It is always a pleasure to read the experiences of a new pipe smoker.
Before you realize it, you will be an expert on packing your pipe.