Skippy's Blend of the Week

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Good stuff Maynard! Neither float my boat, and the biggest difference I noted when I tried them when I picked up were that the “labeled” pouch blends get a PG treatment and the bulk get much less.
Great review though, and I’m looking forward to the twist review.
I always get the Black Irish X, and the Brown Bogie/Brown Twist. I believe the browns are the same, just “X” and “Twist” being a different spin thickness.
Slaínte

I had debated about whether or not to include that bit about the propylene glycol preservative on Captain Black, but having never tasted propylene glycol on it's own I'm not sure I could recognize it if it was there! I know the Captain Black line as a whole is more heavily topped with something sticky and sweet than Lane's bulk blends, and it would make sense for it to be a PG preservative since a lot of those pouches are destined to sit around on smoke shop shelves for a good long time before anyone purchases them, but not knowing exactly what PG tastes like I felt like it was safest to just say that Captain Black is more heavily topped than Lane's bulk blends and leave it at that. Could be flavorings, could be PG, I don't know; but it sure is more heavily topped with something! 😅

I'm really looking forward to doing the Brown Irish X review too, especially since I've never tried it before. I have had Brown Bogie, which I mostly enjoyed aside from the presence of what I can only guess was a sugar syrup topping on the wrapper leaves; since it was even sweeter than Captain Black! If it wasn't for that sugary sweet topping I would have really loved Brown Bogie, so I'm hoping Gawith chose to omit the topping for Brown Irish X.

I have had Black Irish X once before as well and thankfully that one wasn't the least bit sweet, though I wasn't sure what to make of the flavor. To me it basically tasted like I crammed my pipe full of char grilled meat and decided to smoke it, which was... interesting. It definitely wasn't a boring blend by any means, but may be one that requires a full week of proper evaluation to really make up my mind on. It's in a jar on my shelf and on the list to review though, along with the more medium strength Kendal No.7 and Curly Cut Deluxe.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Brown Irish X is exactly the same as Brown Bogie, its just thicker. There is no sugary topping added to the plain twists.

Black Irish (or Bogie) is brown then oil and cooked. But same leaf composition.

Well that's good to know! I wonder if the sample of Happy Brown Bogie I had previously was just stored together with a sugary aromatic at the retailer before it came to me, because wow was it ever sweet! I know Virginias can sometimes have a natural sweetness to them, but that Brown Bogie was full-on Sutliff aromatic sweet! 😅

In any case, I'm a big fan of Gawith's dark fired offerings (Kendal Dark and Kendal Mixed especially) so I'm really looking forward to giving my couple ounce samples of Brown Irish X, Black Irish X, Curly Cut Deluxe, and Kendal No.7 a try! If I end up liking Brown Irish X I'll have to give Brown Bogie another shot too. puffy
 
  • Like
Reactions: Steddy and Kollman

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Are you sure you did not get maple flavoured maybe as that has added sugar and sweetness.

It's entirely possible! The sample was sent to me by a small US vendor as part of a free random assortment of Gawith blends since they knew Gawith Hoggarth & Co. is my favorite blending house but there's many of your blends I've yet to try, and the bag it was in was simply labeled "Happy Brown Bogie" so it certainly could have been the maple flavored variety.
 

Sobrbiker

Lifer
Jan 7, 2023
6,548
89,406
Casa Grande, AZ
It's entirely possible! The sample was sent to me by a small US vendor as part of a free random assortment of Gawith blends since they knew Gawith Hoggarth & Co. is my favorite blending house but there's many of your blends I've yet to try, and the bag it was in was simply labeled "Happy Brown Bogie" so it certainly could have been the maple flavored variety.
Maple Twist is definitely sweeter than the Happy Brown and Brown Twist (sliced) I’ve gotten, does kind of sound like an old “switcheroo” may be at play.

Edit to add: SG Black XX is less “meaty” than the GH&Co Black X
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skippy Piper

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
I am pleased to report after smoking my first pipe of Brown Irish X that there is no added sweetness whatsoever, and it's a darn fine tobacco! I'll have to smoke it for a week to really work out my thoughts on it, but I think this one is really going to give Kendal Dark a run for its money for the title of my favorite dark fired blend! puffy
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Jeez, I sure picked a bad time to try to review some dark strong rope tobacco! Between the 95°F heat every day the past week here in Minnesota and the smoke from the Canadian wildfires clogging up the sky and bugging my throat and lungs all week I haven't been in much of a mood to smoke a strong dark fired blend.

I've actually only smoked Brown Irish X exactly once in the past week and have just been smoking (gasp) Lane 1-Q the rest of the time, which is pretty much the polar opposite of what I was supposed to be smoking in terms of body, flavor, and strength! 😅

On the plus side, the skies have finally cleared up and my throat is calming down so maybe this week I can do Brown Irish X? In any case, I think this is gonna be one of those, "It'll be ready when it's ready" sorta reviews.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Blend of the Week #25: Lane Limited TK-6
It's Cult Blood Red Moon.

Another week has gone by and I still haven't managed to convince myself to smoke Brown Irish X even once yet on account of the insufferable heat and humidity, though I have been smoking a lot of Lane TK-6 and after puffing on this one for a week I'm starting to become convinced that it is a little different than Cult Blood Red Moon.

I'll have to give it a proper review later on, but my overall impression after smoking it for a week is that Lane TK-6 is to Cult Blood Red Moon what Lane RLP-6 is to Captain Black Original. The same toppings are there, but in much more subdued proportions so you get noticably more Burley tobacco flavor, a bit less of a cherry punch, and the chocolate and vanilla are both toned down enough that they could go unnoticed if you weren't actively looking for them.

TK-6 is also a good bit less sweet than Blood Red Moon and doesn't have the syrupy quality that I've always found Blood Red Moon to have, especially on the finish towards the bottom of the bowl. I'm currently out of Blood Red Moon so I don't have a tin to directly compare it to right now, but going from memory of the three tins of Blood Red Moon I've smoked through in the past I do think TK-6 is a bit different; possibly for the better.

I'll have to pick up a new tin of Blood Red Moon and do a direct comparison. puffy
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Alrighty, I think it's time for a change of plans! I don't know if it's the 95°F heat every day or the 85% to 90% humidity 24/7 but I have just not been enjoying this Brown Irish X rope tobacco any of the times I've forced myself to smoke it this past week, and I don't want to give what's probably a quite good tobacco a bad review just because I've had a foul disposition from summer weather, so I'm putting Brown Irish X back on the shelf until the cooler autumn or winter weather rolls around and I feel like smoking it.

I figure the whole point of pipe smoking is to be a relaxing and enjoyable leisure activity, and if I'm having to force myself to do it because I'm just not enjoying what I'm smoking then it's time to change things up and smoke a different blend that I'll be more inclined to enjoy and look forward to smoking. I think I'll do Lane TK-6 next, since I've been liking that one quite a bit lately. puffy
 

BriaronBoerum

Can't Leave
Jan 13, 2025
411
1,923
Brooklyn, NY
Funny, I recently got an ounce of this same blend and tried it last week while out with a friend. Good and strong, but I totally agree, it's not for hot weather, and we're looking at at least 3 days of upper 90s here in Brooklyn! Can't remember if you've reviewed Lane HGL or RLP-6 yet, which were big surprises for me, in a positive sense?
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Funny, I recently got an ounce of this same blend and tried it last week while out with a friend. Good and strong, but I totally agree, it's not for hot weather, and we're looking at at least 3 days of upper 90s here in Brooklyn! Can't remember if you've reviewed Lane HGL or RLP-6 yet, which were big surprises for me, in a positive sense?

I haven't had HGL before, but my last review on the previous page was actually RLP-6!



Lane blends often get a bad rap and find themselves lumped in with the wet and goopy Sutliff aromatics of olde, but personally I've really enjoyed the vast majority of Lane blends I've smoked and haven't found them to be overly wet, goopy, or difficult to keep lit at all. If you're someone who likes mellow aromatics (which I most certainly am) then I think Lane is probably the best producer of aromatic tobaccos still in business today.

So far I've tried 1-Q, LL-7, RLP-6, BL/WB, BCA, Black Raspberry, Very Cherry, and TK-6 and liked them all to varying degrees; and I still have jars of Hazelnut and Buttered Rum that I've yet to get around to trying. puffy
 

Kollman

Starting to Get Obsessed
Nov 5, 2024
261
390
No Name, CO
I think you are right on track to switch gears and pick something enjoyable for the season, or at least as much as you can in the 90F/90% weather. This is supposed to be enjoyable, relaxing, and fun. I suggest pulling out 3 summer options and letting somebody else pick the blend you dive into this week. It helps to shake off the stress of it all. Ha ha
 

Bassman65

Part of the Furniture Now
Nov 30, 2022
770
1,330
Canada
I haven't had HGL before, but my last review on the previous page was actually RLP-6!



Lane blends often get a bad rap and find themselves lumped in with the wet and goopy Sutliff aromatics of olde, but personally I've really enjoyed the vast majority of Lane blends I've smoked and haven't found them to be overly wet, goopy, or difficult to keep lit at all. If you're someone who likes mellow aromatics (which I most certainly am) then I think Lane is probably the best producer of aromatic tobaccos still in business today.

So far I've tried 1-Q, LL-7, RLP-6, BL/WB, BCA, Black Raspberry, Very Cherry, and TK-6 and liked them all to varying degrees; and I still have jars of Hazelnut and Buttered Rum that I've yet to get around to trying. puffy
I’ve always enjoyed the Lane products. Too bad they are quite difficult to get up here.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Blend of the Week #31: Lane Limited TK-6

IMG_2583~2.JPG


I've always had a bit of a contentious relationship with cherry aromatics. I love the idea of a cherry flavored tobacco, but there's almost always something about them that just wears poorly on my palate after repeated smokes. Most of them have a somewhat medicinal cherry cough syrup background note that becomes more and more obvious each time I smoke it until it's the main thing I end up tasting every time, and the few that don't have that cough syrup note all have their own issues.

I love the bright and juicy candy cherry Tootsie pop flavor of Paladin Black Cherry, but it has by far the most absolutely vicious sinus stinging retrohale of any blend I've ever smoked. You don't dare breathe even a wisp of it out of your nose unless you happen to enjoy the feeling of your sinuses being flooded with battery acid. Lane Very Cherry is a long-time favorite of mine in the cherry aromatic department that doesn't have any retrohale issues, but the flavor isn't really "cherry" so much as it is a mix of cherry, almond, cinnamon, and vanilla which creates a sort of cherry danish pastry overall flavor profile that—while delightful in it's own way—has proven to be just not really what I'm looking for in a cherry blend over the long haul. What I'm really after is just a straightforward "tobacco and cherry" blend without much in the way of other flavors involved.

Smoker's Pride Cherry Cavendish does give me that straight cherry flavor I'm looking for fresh out of the bag, but as it ages in a jar over a period of months the medicinal cough syrup note becomes more and more prominent until it takes over the blend. Cult Blood Red Moon hits probably the closest to what I'm looking for in a cherry blend, but I could do without all the extra chocolate and vanilla flavors and it does tend to have a very syrupy quality to the smoke; like a fountain drink that wasn't mixed quite right and had way too much syrup and not enough carbonated water so it ends up tasting sickly sweet. I also find Blood Red Moon to be completely devoid of any nicotine whatsoever.

This is where Lane TK-6 comes in. Appearance wise it looks quite similar to Blood Red Moon, coming in a fairly wide and chunky ribbon cut mixture of Black Cavendish and Burley tobaccos, but is less wet and sticky feeling between the fingers and only slightly moist. The tin aroma smells just like Blood Red Moon as well, with that same sweet candied cherry scent that has just a bit of chocolate and vanilla wafting around in the back. It's no surprise that it does though, since Lane is the manufacturer for both blends and when smoked TK-6 reveals that it does indeed have the same cherry topping as Cult Blood Red Moon; but the chocolate and vanilla notes have been toned way down to the point that they're barely noticable even when you're actively looking for them. In fact, I'm not sure there's even any chocolate topping in there at all and the mild cocoa note I get a little hint of every now and then might just be a naturally occuring flavor of the Burley tobacco in the mix.

The quantity of cherry topping added has been reduced significantly as well, which I think is a good thing since it makes the smoke no longer syrupy or overly sweet and lets more of the natural woody, nutty, chocolatey Burley tobacco flavor shine through. TK-6 is still a somewhat sweet tasting aromatic blend, but it never becomes sickly sweet and even after smoking it every day for 2 weeks I've yet to find myself tiring of it or noticing any medicinal cough syrupiness. It's a really well balanced blend suitable for all day smoking if you've got a taste for cherry aromatics, and it wears on the palate nicely over time with no unwanted flavor notes. The reduced quantity of toppings also means that TK-6 thankfully doesn't leave your pipe a soaking wet mess after smoking like Blood Red Moon does. You'll still probably want to give the inside of the bowl a quick wipe down with a paper towel after the pipe is done, since it does leave behind a little bit of moisture and sticky residue, but vastly less than Blood Red Moon and other similarly wet aromatic tobaccos.

In terms of TK-6's smoking mechanics, it takes to the flame and burns quite well straight out of the jar with no dry time required, and will smoke down to the bottom of the bowl with few (if any) relights required. It's a very well behaved blend mechanically speaking and can be puffed fairly vigorously without turning harsh or unpleasant tasting, though it can start to taste a touch burnt if you really freight train it or smoke it outdoors on a windy day. On another positive note, the retrohale is quite smooth and gentle on the sinuses; offering a better taste of all the flavors at play without any stinging or burning sensation. Like many Lane blends, TK-6 is one that new pipe smokers should have no trouble getting a good flavorful smoke from. It's got a little bit of nicotine in it, which for me is much appreciated since TK-6 doesn't leave me scrambling to rush out for a cigarette after finishing a pipe like Blood Red Moon does, but it's still a pretty small amount and not enough to trouble a new pipe smoker unfamiliar with the wiles of Lady N. I'd say it's about at the center of mild on the nicotine scale.


I think the best simple description I could give for this blend is that Lane TK-6 is to Cult Blood Red Moon what Lane RLP-6 is to Captain Black Original. The same toppings are there, but toned down enough that the blend is no longer overly sweet and more suitable for all day smoking; and you get a good bit more natural tobacco flavor as well. I'm a big fan of RLP-6 too, it's probably my all time favorite aromatic tobacco overall, so it's no surprise that Lane TK-6 has quickly become my new favorite cherry aromatic! This is one of those blends that just gets everything right in my book, and cherry blends in particular are awfully difficult to get right, so I'm pleased to say that TK-6 is a definite keeper for me and will be replacing both Lane Very Cherry and Cult Blood Red Moon on my keeper shelf. It's my new go-to cherry blend that really ticks all the boxes in terms of what I look for in a cherry aromatic, and since I know from experience that Lane aromatics tend to cellar unusually well and retain their flavor for many years in a jar, I'll be ordering a pound of TK-6 once I finish up the small jar I have left. It's king of the cherry hill in my book! puffy





Looking ahead to the coming weeks, there's only about a month of summer left up here in Minnesota before the autumn chill begins to set in, so I think August would be a good month to focus on the assortment of Virginia based blends I've been meaning to review. While I like smoking aromatics year round, Virginias are very much a warm weather tobacco for me and I enjoy them most during the spring and summer; just like how I prefer to smoke dark fired and English blends during the colder autumn and winter months.

To start off the Virginia month I'll be revisiting a blend that I remember enjoying very much in my early days of pipe smoking and smoked through a whole tin of a couple years back, and while I generally avoid blends containing Perique since it tends to bug my throat, I don't remember the tiny bit of Perique in this one ever bothering me in that regard. What I do remember though is this blend tasting like all the aromas of a warm summer day. Wildflower meadows, dandelions, green grass, and iced tea with a squeeze of lemon. Whether or not it still tastes like that to me is yet to be seen, but either way I'll find out because next week's blend of the week is...


Orlik Golden Sliced

IMG_2608~2.JPG
 
Last edited:

khiddy

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 21, 2024
964
4,497
South Bend, Indiana
blog.hallenius.org
Great post and review, Skip. I actually picked up some Lane Very Cherry on your recommendation last year, and discovered that it was definitely not for me – it was too medicinally syrupy for my palate. But I set it aside, and ended up blending most of it into my own home version of Hobbit Weed, which toned it down sufficiently that I have smoked through most of the jar that I bought, so no harm, no foul. Perhaps when this is gone, I'll try a few ounces of TK-6.

Keep up the good work.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
Great post and review, Skip. I actually picked up some Lane Very Cherry on your recommendation last year, and discovered that it was definitely not for me – it was too medicinally syrupy for my palate. But I set it aside, and ended up blending most of it into my own home version of Hobbit Weed, which toned it down sufficiently that I have smoked through most of the jar that I bought, so no harm, no foul. Perhaps when this is gone, I'll try a few ounces of TK-6.

Keep up the good work.

Aw man, I'm sorry for the letdown with the Lane Very Cherry! I try to be as objective as I can when it comes to tasting tobaccos, but I know at the end of the day everyone's tastes are subjective and cherry blends are pretty notorious when it comes to that medicinal cough syrup note that some people will taste and others won't.

I sure didn't notice any in the couple ounces of Very Cherry I had, but then again my stash had been sitting in a jar for two years before I reviewed it so maybe that medicinal note just faded over time. I definitely noticed a medicinal cough syrupy note in the fresh pouch of Captain Black Cherry I got a few months ago though, which in all other regards seemed identical to Lane Very Cherry, so it's entirely possible that Very Cherry has that same cough syrupy quality when it's fresh and hasn't spent a couple years sitting in a jar. Still, my apologies if you felt misled by my review!
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: Kollman and khiddy