Read This Before Concluding ANYTHING Regarding Blend Preferences

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
965
11,454
St. Paul, MN
I think I'm taste-challenged (somehow the term undertaster is vaguely unsettling) but it has its upside...I'm not usually disappointed and more easily satisfied.

As funny as that is, you've actually got a really good point. I'm a supertaster myself and I've been through just over 100 pipe blends (and well over $1,000) trying to find a blend I really liked that didn't have something about it that bothered me. Bright Virginias are always too sharp and acidic (most people seem to taste bright Virginias as sweet but to me they're just lemon juice acidy), Red Virginias taste like dead wet leaves in the autumn, the dirty earthiness of Burleys gets off-putting after awhile, Latakia mostly tastes like I licked a dirty fireplace, and Perique gives my mouth fits.

So ya know what I keep coming back to? Captain Black Original. A thousand dollars and a hundred fancy boutique pipe blends later and my most enjoyed smoke is the most pedestrian, lowest common denominator vanilla cream aromatic there is. I guess it just goes to show that having good taste buds doesn't necessarily mean you have good taste. 😅
 

brian64

Lifer
Jan 31, 2011
10,617
18,077
As funny as that is, you've actually got a really good point. I'm a supertaster myself and I've been through just over 100 pipe blends (and well over $1,000) trying to find a blend I really liked that didn't have something about it that bothered me. Bright Virginias are always too sharp and acidic (most people seem to taste bright Virginias as sweet but to me they're just lemon juice acidy), Red Virginias taste like dead wet leaves in the autumn, the dirty earthiness of Burleys gets off-putting after awhile, Latakia mostly tastes like I licked a dirty fireplace, and Perique gives my mouth fits.

So ya know what I keep coming back to? Captain Black Original. A thousand dollars and a hundred fancy boutique pipe blends later and my most enjoyed smoke is the most pedestrian, lowest common denominator vanilla cream aromatic there is. I guess it just goes to show that having good taste buds doesn't necessarily mean you have good taste. 😅

I feel for you…I would hate to have that level of taste sensitivity…I can’t imagine not being able to smoke Perique.
 

SSGT.

Part of the Furniture Now
Jul 7, 2024
553
3,338
Sealy Texas
The undertasters can't hang, and they never will.
You type that as if it's a bad thing.

I actually enjoy having under achieving taste buds I may not know what bready Virginias and creamy cavendish actually taste like, but I know what taste good and I don't fret over "well the burley doesn't come into play until halfway through the bowl". my buds just tell me damned we just got another taste going on here.
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
18,342
33,328
47
Central PA a.k.a. State College
As funny as that is, you've actually got a really good point. I'm a supertaster myself and I've been through just over 100 pipe blends (and well over $1,000) trying to find a blend I really liked that didn't have something about it that bothered me. Bright Virginias are always too sharp and acidic (most people seem to taste bright Virginias as sweet but to me they're just lemon juice acidy), Red Virginias taste like dead wet leaves in the autumn, the dirty earthiness of Burleys gets off-putting after awhile, Latakia mostly tastes like I licked a dirty fireplace, and Perique gives my mouth fits.

So ya know what I keep coming back to? Captain Black Original. A thousand dollars and a hundred fancy boutique pipe blends later and my most enjoyed smoke is the most pedestrian, lowest common denominator vanilla cream aromatic there is. I guess it just goes to show that having good taste buds doesn't necessarily mean you have good taste. 😅
Or at least it shows that taste is a very personal experience and not really something to judge a person over.