Dunhill & Escudo Navy De Luxe the Same?
-
Kevin Godbee - Nov 16, 2010
- 1 min read
As I’m sitting here writing a review of Dunhill De Luxe Navy Rolls and describing what it is like, I suddenly realized that it reminded me of Escudo Navy De Luxe. Then I realized that they are both made in the same factory and both have Virginia and Perique. I stopped my review of Dunhill De Luxe Navy Rolls, for the second time in two weeks. Last time I found that the distribution and availability was in question – article here. Now I’ve shifted into a side-by-side comparison.
The similarities between Dunhill De Luxe Navy Rolls and Escudo Navy De Luxe are numerous. Are they actually the exact same thing in two different packages?
Dunhill De Luxe Navy Rolls & Escudo Navy De Luxe Similarities:
1. Both contain Virginia and Perique tobaccos.
2. Both have the same name with one word placed differently.
3. Both are rolled and then sliced into coins.
4. They are the same type of blend – Navy-style.
5. They are made in the same factory – Orlik.
Are they one and the same? Let’s look a little closer.
In the above picture, Dunhill is obviously on the left and Escudo is clearly on the right. Would you be able to tell which was which if the top of the tins weren’t placed by their respective tobaccos?
Let’s take an even closer look at the coins side-by-side.
You can see the above photo even larger when you click on it. They look quite similar, but with this closer inspection, they do start to look a little different. The Escudo appears to have some more yellow Virginia tobacco and the Dunhill (again on the left) appears a little darker.
So, the next question to answer is; "What do they actually taste like when smoked side-by-side?" I have smoked them both at the same time alternating back and forth in two pipes that are exactly the same shape and size.
Stay tuned to PipesMagazine.com to find out if Dunhill De Luxe Navy Rolls and Escudo Navy De Luxe are one in the same.
Written by Kevin Godbee
15 Responses
Recent Posts
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 640. Our featured interview on tonight’s show is with Ben Rapaport. Ben has been known internationally as an avid pipe smoker, antique pipe collector, and book author. His first book on pipes was published in 1972, and his latest book – his 10th – is out now in very limited quantities. The distribution has already sold out, but you can still get a copy of “The Wide World of Wood Tobacco Pipes. Two Centuries of Craftsmanship and Creativity” by contacting him directly at ben70gray@gmail.com. At the top of the show we’ll be turning the tables on our recurring Ask the Pipemaker segment. This time, Jeff Gracik will ask the questions, which Brian will answer as a pipe collector, and you can give your answers too.
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 639. Our featured interview on tonight’s show is with Per Billhäll. Per is the owner of Scandinavian Pipes, which is an online retailer of high grade pipes. He started smoking pipes in the 1960s. His first high grade pipe was made by Hans “Former” Nielsen, who is one of the living legends from Denmark. That led to Per becoming a huge pipe and tobacco collector, and show attendee where he became well known. Along with pipe book author Jan Andersson, they started The Pipe Club of Sweden in 1991. Then in 1999, Per started “Scan Pipes”. He is now one of the pipe retailing legends from Sweden. At the top of the show Brian will talk about holiday blends, and other special pipe tobacco blends.
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 638. Our featured interview on tonight’s show is with Fae “The Sassy Pipe Lady” Simmons. Fae is the owner of Tobacco Treasures, which sells new, vintage, & estate pipes, and smoking accessories on Etsy. She has been in business since 2017, and has been surrounded by pipes and tobacco most of her life. Her father and his brother smoked pipes, and so does Fae. Her husband is also a retired tobacconist that worked all over the industry from coast to coast for several different companies in the industry. She has a great story of how her business got started with a great inventory of unsmoked vintage pipes. At the top of the show we will have an Ask the Tobacco Blender segment with Jeremy Reeves. Jeremy is the Head Blender at Cornell & Diehl, which is one of the most popular boutique pipe tobacco companies in the USA.
Ok, so it’s that time of year, as we all know. Family feasts, houses, yards, and big trees festooned with lights and dangling ornaments, just high enough to keep the cats from reaching a paw into the greenery. It’s also the time of year when your pipe-smoking-significant other makes vast hints about a new pipe. That’s to be expected since he or she was a good boy or girl during the year. Yes, ladies smoke pipes, too. Oh, you want an example? Okay, try Actress Greta Garbo, Millicent Fenwick, Mary Frith, and my late grandmother (who died when she was 93) dipped snuff and smoked a cob occasionally. So now that we have settled that the gentler side of life will puff a pipe too, let’s move on to the upcoming biggest holiday of all. Of course, that huge event is brought to us by the hefty fellow in a red suit, puffing his pipe all the way in a sled filled with presents, being led by a reindeer with a red nose. Or some such. That’s Santa Claus, of course. Becoming a bit more serious, Christmas is such a wonderful time for families and friends. It’s also quite special for pipe puffers. For many of us, this brings up a nostalgic look back to our pipe-smoking or cigar-smoking friends who have died during the current year. A great journalist pal whom I often joined in a local brick-and-mortar pipe and cigar shop. I puffed my pipe, and occasional cigar, as he enjoyed a cigar. He died in October and will be missed. On the happier side of things, Christmas is also a time when mind workers of the world renew their collections with fresh additions. Pundit included. A French passion has overtaken Pundit, from reading more Albert Camus, a heavy cigarette smoker, as were many French intellectuals of a certain time. Instead of cigarettes many of us prefer the more relaxed enjoyment of pipes for that “calm and objective judgment” in the comings and goings of the world. This brings me to French pipes. While visiting France once in the long ago, I happened by a “Tabac” shop in Paris, Tabac Des Vosges. I purchased a beauty of a Chacom bent. I also later bought a Ropp made from ancient briar. To learn more about the dawn of briar pipes and beginnings, take a peek at a well-done piece by Davin Hylton in Pipe Line on April 12, 2023, on Saint-Claude, France, the birthplace of briar. Also in the long back when, on a cold Christmas afternoon, Pundit wandered into an Atlanta bricks and mortar pipe shop to look around. There, resting in an enclosed glass counter was an exquisite Comoy. An older gent, smoking a beautiful bent, asked me if I wanted to look at that pipe. It had a $100 price tag. A college student working for a grocery store chain to help with college tuition at the time, Pundit didn’t have one hundred cents, let alone a C note! I declined and found a $5 basket pipe. A Christmas tradition had just begun. Since that early time, Pundit has made it a holiday ritual to either reward himself, or a special friend, with pipe or tobacco. A Claudio Cavicchi would be nice. Just sayin.’ And now for a couple of December-born Pipe Smokers of the Past: Joseph Rudyard Kipling was born on Dec. 30, 1865, and died on Jan. 18, 1936. I always prefer to believe the best of everybody; it saves so much trouble—Rudyard Kipling. Martin Van Buren, born Dec. 5, 1782, and died July 24, 1862, U.S. President, 1837-1841 As to the presidency, the two happiest days of my life were those of my entrance upon the office and my surrender of it—Martin Van Buren. And one more note to recall a deceased World War II veteran who loved William Somerset Maugham, the author. Maugham, a pipe smoker, was born in Paris, France, on Jan. 25, 1874, and died on Dec. 16, 1965. One cool afternoon as the veteran and I talked while sitting in his backyard patio, he looked off into the distance as if studying something. Nothing in particular. Just looking. He turned to me and said if I wanted to learn about life, “read Somerset Maugham.” I did. It wasn’t until late in life that I discovered how easy it is to say, ‘I don’t know’ –W. Somerset Maugham And now a Parting Shot: Any day with an old friend with pipes and tobacco is a good day.
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 637. Our featured interview on tonight’s show is with Nate King. Most people know of Nate as an excellent pipe artisan. He also has an honorary Master of Pipes degree from the Chicagoland Pipe Collectors Club, and is a member of the prestigious Confrérie des Maitres Pipiers de Saint-Claude. To be inducted into the Confrérie, this past May Nate travelled to Saint-Claude, France with master tobacco blender G.L. Pease, who was also inducted. It was quite a time in France, and at the ceremony. We’ll hear all about those adventures on the show. At the top of the show we’ll continue the virtual tour of Brian’s pipe collection with six of his Satou Dublin-shape pipes.
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 636. Our featured interview on tonight’s show is with Barry Kane. Barry started smoking a pipe in 1961 when he was 14-years old. Back then it seemed like everybody smoked, and you could buy pipes and tobacco just about anywhere. Barry is a true old-school pipe smoker, sticking to just one blend. See if you can guess which one before listening. At the top of the show Brian will give his take on Scandinavian Tobacco Group’s purchase of Mac Baren and Sutliff Tobacco and their announcement that they will be shut down.
I agree it certainly appears the Escudo has more Va in it. My vote is they are a bit different but probably not a lot.
Good Day.
A long time ago I smoked the Dunhill Luxary Rolls, and while similar to the A&C Escudo, the Dunhill had a far more sweet tone. The A&C Escudo a more citric edge. Both are vastly different than the original Cope’s Escudo. That being said, I do and have enjoyed all three.
Regards
Michael J. Glukler
On the labels, under the name you will find an identical pen-stroke flourish.
The coin diameters look about the same. Are the coins the same thickness?
To me it looks like the proportions of bright & dark leaf are different. Are these two coins representative samples? Or do they represent the extremes of the brightness spectrum. Did you, or can you ask anyone at Orlik? — maybe that cute girl who worked with the Orlik Golden Slices.
I understand that the Escudo is made by Peter Stokkebye. Would suspect
there’s more Virginia in the Escudo than the Dunhill. I love
Stokkebye because it’s always full of flavor no matter which
blend and equally mild. Can’t wait to hear about your experiment.
Cheers
Stephen Spring
Send me a tin of the Dunhill and I’ll help with the review!
It would be also be a good thing to ascertain if both tins are of the same age. I find that tobaccos tend to darken in the tin with age. If they are identical tobaccos but one is older, the tasting results could be less than decisive.
I agree with Mike Glukler regarding the difference between the two. The old Cope’s Escudo is the gold standard to which current production aspires but does not equal. Escudo seems to have more a fruity, spicy bite than Dunhill, which I would attribute to a higher perique content and/or lower sugar content in the Virginia component.
I’m with Gunner777 on this one I believe there to be more Virginia in the Escudo.
I can’t speak the the Dunhill, but I know I love the Escudo Navy De Luxe.
Good question Kevin.
Lawrence
cortezattic said: “On the labels, under the name you will find an identical pen-stroke flourish.”
Oh yeah! How did I miss that! There are exactly the same, and my other Dunhill tins do not have that mark.
cortezattic said: “The coin diameters look about the same. Are the coins the same thickness?
To me it looks like the proportions of bright & dark leaf are different. Are these two coins representative samples?”
The diameters and thickness are the same, and the coins are representative samples.
Interestingly, when you look at the coins with the naked eye, they look the same. It is only in the close-up photography that they look different.
stephenspring said: “I understand that the Escudo is made by Peter Stokkebye.”
Stokkebye tobaccos are made by Scandanavian Tobacco Group, which owns the Orlik factory. The Orlik factory makes all the Stokkebye branded blends, and all the other brands that are imported and distributed by Villiger Stokkebye, International.
You can read about that here:
https://pipesmagazine.com/blog/pipe-manufacturer-retailer-spotlight/erik-stokkebye-of-villiger-stokkebye-international/
yachtexplorer said: “It would be also be a good thing to ascertain if both tins are of the same age. I find that tobaccos tend to darken in the tin with age. If they are identical tobaccos but one is older, the tasting results could be less than decisive.”
Good points yachtexplorer. It is hard to know the exact answer, but here is what I do know. I acquired the Escudo tin about a year ago and I received the Dunhill tin 3.5 months ago. However, the Dunhill tin has been unsealed for 3 months and I just opened the Escudo tin this morning.
The Escudo tin aroma is much stronger than the Dunhill. It is sweeter and the Dunhill is more hay-like. This is probably because the Dunhill tin has been open longer. However, when taking individual coins from each tin and smelling them, they seem about the same.
Ah, two classics that I havn’t tried yet. The Escudo’s been on my list forever it seems … Gotta do something about that soon! Also been eyeballing Orlik Bullseye for a while.
Thanks for the read + beautiful pictures, Kevin!
I can’t fully compare the two yet as I’ve not smoke the Navy Rolls, but the general consensus is that Escudo is more spicy and citrus-y. I would agree, Escudo has a nice Citrus-spice flavor to it.
I used to smoke Cope’s Escudo all the time so it was a real letdown when the new recipe came out. The one I really miss is Balkan Sobraine 759!
Dunhill has a darker toned virginia, may this be due to aging? This may cause a sweeter and softer smoke…
I just got a tin of the Navy Escudo by Stokkebye and I really like it. The taste of perique comes through moderately and the virginia is definitely there. I have never tried the Dunhill, but I would relish the opportunity to try it.
Here is my update:
https://pipesmagazine.com/blog/kevins-blog/dunhill-escudo-navy-de-luxe-the-verdict/