J.M. Boswell, Stradivari of the Pipe World

Fred Brown
To believe your own thought, to believe that what is true for you in your private heart is true for all men—that is genius—Ralph Waldo Emmerson, "Self-Reliance" Essay, Boston, 1841

J.M. Boswell is the living embodiment of self-reliance, a belief that the ultimate source of truth lies within himself.

Lofty? Perhaps, but J.M. Boswell is a professional pipe maker of rare talent. He makes a perfect pipe because it is true to his code: it has to be flawless, or he will not let it leave his shop in Chambersburg, Pa.

You have no doubt heard of Boswell pipes. He has become, in many estimations, a kind of guru at the top of the mountain, dispensing vast knowledge about the mystique of pipe smoking.

If you haven’t heard, then get on your computer and go to the Boswell web page or on Instagram.

J.M. is one of America’s premiere pipe makers, although he will not tell you that. In fact, about all J.M. will say is, "I’m just like anyone else.

"I like what I do. It is a business. That is how I do it. You don’t have a business without people giving you their hard-earned money."

2nd Floor Smoking Parlor

Take it from the Pipe Pundit. Simply stated, his pipes smoke! The holes are drilled for easy draw. The button is opened up to assist in effortless puffing. Boswell pipes are a pleasure, period.

The history behind J.M. Boswell and his shop in Chambersburg is a classic American story, coming from nothing to the status of master craftsman, an artist of the first rank. J.M. Boswell is the Antonio Stradivari of pipe makers.

The signs on his pipe store in Chambersburg explain most of the history. There are two of them, one over the store entrance and the other hanging on a post: Over the entry, it says: "J.M. Boswell’s Pipes & Tobacco." The sign in front of the shop says: "Boswell’s Pipes and Cigars."

As you walk into store sitting area on left, large walk in Humidor on Right

J.M. has been making pipes "in the hands on procedure in old world tradition" since 1975.

We pick up the story with J.M. a 10-year-old whose family had recently moved from Elba, Ala., where he was born, to Carlisle, Pa., where his father worked as a master welder.

J.M. says his father could do anything with his hands, and when he was 10 years old, he also worked with his dad and discovered he, too, had a gift with his hands.

"From the time I was 10, I was never broke again," is how J.M. puts it. In other words, he realized he could always make a living with his hands.

Boswell Briar wood delivery

After moving to Carlisle, J.M. got a job delivering newspapers. Later, he began working with Richard Johnson, who owned a small pipe-shop operation in Carlisle. Johnson had worked for the legendary Weber Pipe Co. of Jersey City, N.J., as had his younger brother, Kenneth, father of J.M.’s wife, Gail. His wife’s aunt had also worked for Weber, one of the giant production pipe makers of the 1950s-1980s.

At first, J.M. says, he didn’t have much interest in pipes. Johnson was not making many pipes at the time, but within a couple of weeks, J.M. had caught on, and caught the pipe-making bug.

"If you show me something, I can do it, pretty much with anything."

Thus, the gestation of one of America’s finest pipe makers began.

Boswells J.M. Gail Julie and Dan

While passing through Chambersburg on his way to start a new job, J.M. saw a store on the town’s main street that had a sign in the window: "Will remodel to suit."

"I told Gail that’s where we were going to open our pipe shop."

The year was 1980. The store was 10 feet wide and 28 feet deep, J.M. says.

A year later, he had to move to a store three times the size of the first one. In 1997, he moved into his present location, 586 Lincoln Way East in historic Chambersburg.

Dan buffing his Weathered Stone Pipe

Everything he owned, he says, went into that business in the building that had once served as a pharmacy.

From there, he made pipes and restored pipes. His pipes sailed out of the Chambersburg shop to retail B&Ms around the nation under different names.

J.M. attended pipe shows. He sold his pipes wherever he could. He worked in his shop during the day, and carved pipes into the wee hours of the morning.

After beginning his shop in 1980, he was sending repaired pipes to more than 400 shops just two years later.

By 1990, J.M. was distributing his hand-made pipes to stores across the nation. His wife, Gail, handled the packaging and mailing.

Gail, Titus, & J.M.

"We made a lot of pipes for private labels," J.M. says.

After a few years of this, J.M. says he had $500,000 invested in his business and was busy paying off the balance. He no longer had time to teach others the Boswell method of pipe design.

He either built or redesigned most of the machinery with which he worked. Many aspiring pipe makers showed up at his door, or phoned him, to learn the Boswell wizardry.

Then with his business flourishing, it became too time consuming, since many of those who arrived didn’t know how to use the necessary equipment to create a pipe.

"I don’t have the time (now) to do it. It is very difficult to teach the system we use.

"It is all feel and touch," he says.

As business increased, he brought in his son, Danny, Dan’s wife, Julie, daughter Rachel, who sells estate pipes on eBay, and life partner, Gail, his wife of 39 years.

J.M. Boswell and some of his pipe collections

Gail shoots the photos and keeps up the web site, which was one of the first of the pipe shops to hit the Internet.

Dan has created his own method of working on pipes, which he calls the "weathered stone" look. The process is "done with old- style tools," to rusticate the pipe. It is like etching glass with a chisel.

Boswells is also known for its jumbo pipes, some so large they could past for tree stumps. Well, maybe not that large, but one style is known as the "grizzly." Yeah, it’s big. It’s bad.

Also in the Boswell lineup are shot shell pipes, which have a shell as the band around the stem; and J.M.’s famous nose-warmers, just right for a jacket pocket.

J.M. Cutting a Pipe

Julie handles phone orders while J.M. and Dan work on pipes and tobacco blending. Make no mistake: despite what you may have heard or read, J.M. Boswell creates his own blends. There is no relabeling a manufactured blend in the Boswell world.

Julie Handles the Phone Orders

J.M. takes blending seriously. For instance, his famously popular Northwoods blend took him over three years to perfect before he even allowed it in his shop.

"I started with zero," he says in looking back over his career. "It was hard work and dedication. You have to keep your eyes on the big prize. If it was right, I did it. If it was honest, I did it. If it was shady, I stayed out of it. That just wasn’t the right way. There is only one way and that’s the right way."

J.M.’s philosophy about pipes and pipe making is fairly simple:

The first requirement is that a Boswell pipe has got to "smoke good, look good and be priced so people can afford to buy them."

His pipes sell to the man-on-the-street, the wealthy billionaires who want their company logo on the pipes, and once even to a monk.

And with that in mind, J.M. says he puts in 18 hours a day, seven days a week and has never had a vacation since starting his business four decades ago.

"You are not going to make it if you don’t do that," he says.

And then there is the J.M. approach to honesty. It goes like this:

"You got to do it right. I’ve never cheated anybody. I’ve never made a bill I didn’t pay. I sleep good at night, because I don’t have to worry if I’ve done somebody wrong."

Second Floor has a Tobacciana Museum – Two large rooms packed with antiques

About his briar, J.M. says just like everyone else making pipes today: most of the good wood comes from the Mediterranean.

However, one other little detail separates J.M. from the pack. The briar merchants he deals with go back years and years.

With many of his contacts, he is into second and third generation with a particular family of briar dealers.

He won’t take briar that will require fills, he says, and his merchants know that.

"We have no fills, no fix up time," he says. "We buy the very best wood."

Some of that wood is over 35 years old, and J.M. says if he lives to be 90-years-old, "I won’t have to buy another stick of wood. And at 58 years, he has a lot of good wood.

J.M. has never visited the briar dealers in those Mediterranean lands. He never sees the wood before it arrives.

"They know what I want," he says. "I just wire them the money." He never advances money before the blocks arrive, either.

The pipe-making process is all Boswellian philosophy, just like everything else in the shop.

The hand-tooling part is also simple: band saw, drill press, sander. He drills all the holes in all the pipes.

"All the air holes are (drilled) free hand," he says.

J.M. built the machines to do that job. "I don’t use any jigs for that."

He designed chucks to drill the tenon hole to ensure it is flush. Other than that, he says the rest is all free hand drilling.

And, his machines are made to cut on at 7 a.m. and turn off 12-13 hours later.

Last year, J.M. and his shop turned 4,800 pipes.

As for the Boswell tobacco blends, he has been at that for 40 years as well. He continues to mix his own blends, buying from well-known manufacturing names and then applying his own recipes.

Only organic food flavorings are used in the old fashioned-way of putting the tobacco on cookie sheets to add the flavoring.

"I have a soft palate, so everything we blend, we blend it to be soft."

He has heard all of the naysaying that his blends are simply re-labels from major manufacturers. Not so, says J.M.

"We hear all kinds of stuff. Heard it forever. I don’t read the press or look at the pictures of pipes.

"All it does is create negativity and make you feel harsh about other people.

"Our tobaccos are our tobaccos and that is what we do.

"We have 28 blends and that is it. It takes forever to have a new blend."

As for sales, Boswell pipes and tobaccos are sold worldwide.

"Even to some countries I never heard of," he says.

Just one of the many reasons for Boswell’s success is another one of his basic philosophies:

"I love my store and love my customers. It is most gratifying. I meet the richest guy or the fellow who pays me $5 a week to put a pipe on layaway."

"I’m not better than anyone else. I’m just making sure my family is taken care of and the bills are paid," J.M. says.

"We don’t make pipes we like. We make pipes you want. We make ’em to sell, and that is the bottom line."

Transparency: Fred Brown owns several Boswell pipes and smokes many of the Boswell tobacco blends.



Fred Brown
is a journalist who lives in Knoxville, TN. He will write this column for PipesMagazine.com monthly. He can be contacted at


17 Responses

  • Thanks, pitchfork. J.M. and his entire family are just a real pleasure to work with. They take their work seriously and it shows.

  • Excellent article! My first pipe was a Boswell in 1999. It stills smokes like a champ. It’s also refreshing to see someone like Mr Boswell who holds true to his values and integrity. I hope I can get to PA sometime and visit the shop. That would be a real treat!

  • I have two of his pipes, both are great and purchased directly from their store website. I am also a big fan of their Northwoods. I’d love to actually visit the shop and meet J.M. someday. I’ve had the pleasure of speaking with Dan on the phone a couple of times and he seemed like a good guy.

  • Great article. It introduced me to a number of things about J.M. and his buying sources I was not aware of.
    I do not have one of his pipes yet, although I have been planning to order one for some time. His “shotshell” pipes are my favorite and are a great example of a sportsman’s pipe.
    I have ordered and smoked a number of pounds of Boswell aromatics and have more cellared, and can testify that they are up there with the best on the market, and his prices are more than fair. You really cannot go wrong with any of them.
    Complements will waft behind behind you as thick as your pipe smoke!

  • Great article, I enjoyed it immensely. In the wake of all the news stories of corporate greed and manipulation it’s refreshing to know “old school” values still exist. It restores your faith in humanity. I’m putting Boswell’s on my list of places to visit.

  • I have been smoking JM’s pipes for 20 years. His pipes are great and JM and his family are terrific people. It is always a treat to get to their shop and spend some time there. I never come out without a new pipe. His pipes just keep getting better and better.

  • I have been smoking JM’s pipes since 2007. While living in Carlisle, PA and working at the Army War College, I had the pleasure of meeting J.M. and his son Dan. I would enjoy going to his shop and browsing his pipe display cases. Dan would come out to greet you and roll out a cart with new pipes and show you what was new. Their custom tobacco blends are excellent as well; you just cant beat the experience of being there in person. They were excellent host as well, welcoming all to come in relax in the chairs and even have a smoke with you. The upstairs smoke room is a nice touch as well. I wish I still lived in PA just to be able to go to his shop and hang out! Like billm67 said: His pipes just keep getting better and better!

  • I have 3 Boswells, 4 of their aromatics and 3 or so of their English blends. Every one, every combo smokes great.

  • Shopped here MANY times. Have smoked in the front room. Great environment! Fantastic owner’s and great staff! Looking forward to the opening of their new store. It’s gonna be ALOT closer to me!!!