Which would you choose
- Thread starter bambam
- Start date
SmokingPipes.com Updates
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
I've only tried PA and it was, well, and old codger burley. Not my cup of tea, because it tastes too much like cigarettes to my mind. I've heard that Half and Half isn't as bad, but I'm not buying a tub to find out it's not to my liking. Let us know what you decide on and how it is!
-Jason
P.S.- I moved this to the Pipe Tobacco Discussion sub-forum
-Jason
P.S.- I moved this to the Pipe Tobacco Discussion sub-forum
Half and Half is good stuff, in my opinion. Never tried Prince Albert, so I cant really speak much for it, and the old Walter Raleigh is one of the first blends that I learned to smoke a pipe with. My vote goes for the Half and Half
To be quite honest... I enjoy all 3 OTC's that you listed. PA being my favorite for me out of the 3 listed. H/H smokes and tastes just as good as PA, But PA appeals to me more. SWR also is good to me and can smoke it all day long and be happy, But PA would still be my first choice for myself. :
:
:
can't say for sure, as they are all just too much Burley for me and really taste about the same too....but that's just me. :crazy:
I've never had PA in over 40 years of pipe smoking; hard to believe. Based on that I'd say Half & Half of which I've had many bowls. After all it is "A cargo of contentment."
I would go for Walnut or Carter Hall. Oh wait, I've only had PA among your choices. It wasn't too bad..., but I'd rather have Carter Hall or Walnut! ::
:
- Status