I have two lists below. The first is a list of tobaccos that I've either tried (pipe smoking friends, are friends indeed), or purchased a tin/sample of, and will try. The second is a list of tobaccos I'd like to try, or have been told to consider trying... my "must try list". A note, the first list is shared by a buddy and me. I sorted them by name rather than blend for those like me that are still learning by blend. If this seems more like work than fun, please forgive me and ignore.
CAPTAIN BLACK - WHITE
CORNELL & DIEHL - 107: HAUNTED BOOKSHOP
CORNELL & DIEHL - 970P: PIRATE KAKE
CORNELL & DIEHL - AUTUMN EVENING
CORNELL & DIEHL - BAYOU MORNING
CORNELL & DIEHL - BILLY BUDD
CORNELL & DIEHL - CAPTAIN BOB'S BLEND
CORNELL & DIEHL - EPIPHANY
CORNELL & DIEHL - NIGHT TRAIN
CORNELL & DIEHL - NUTTY IRISHMAN
CORNELL & DIEHL - OLD JOE KRANTZ
CORNELL & DIEHL - ORIENT EXPRESS
CORNELL & DIEHL - THREE FRIARS
DUNHILL - DELUXE NAVY ROLLS
DUNHILL - MY MIXTURE 965
DUNHILL - NIGHTCAP
DUNHILL - VA FLAKE
ERINMORE - FLAKE
ESOTERCIA - DORCHESTER
ESOTERCIA - DUNBAR
ESOTERCIA - MARGATE
ESOTERCIA - PENZANCE
ESOTERCIA - TILBURY
ESOTERICA - PEMBROKE
ESOTERICA - STONEHAVEN
G. L. PEASE - BARBARY COAST
G. L. PEASE - MALTESE FALCON
GAWITH, HOGGARTH & CO. - ENNERDALE FLAKE
HEARTH & HOME - LARRY'S BLEND
JOHN MIDDLETON - CARTER HALL
LANE LIMITED - 1Q
LANE LIMITED - TK-6
MAC BAREN - 7 SEAS GOLD
MAC BAREN - BURLEY LONDON BLEND
MAC BAREN - HH OLD DARK FIRED
MAC BAREN - SCOTTISH BLEND
MC CLELLAND - FROG MORTN
MC CLELLAND - FROG MORTON ON THE BAYOU
MC CLELLAND - NO. 5100 RED CAKE
MC CLELLAND - NO. 5110 DARK ENGLISH
MC CLELLAND - ORIENTAL # 1
MC CLELLAND - THREE OAKS SYRIAN
MC CLELLAND AVENUE BLEND - (DUNHILL MATCH) A.M. PIPE
MC CLELLAND AVENUE BLEND - (DUNHILL MATCH) NINE TO FIVE 925
MC CLELLAND AVENUE BLEND - (DUNHILL MATCH) P.M. PIPE
MC CLELLAND PERSONAL RESERVE - BLACKWOODS FLAKE
PETER STOKKEBYE - BALKAN SUPREME
PETER STOKKEBYE - LUXURY BULLSEYE FLAKE
PETER STOKKEBYE - LUXURY NAVY FLAKES
PETER STOKKEBYE - LUXURY TWIST FLAKE
PLANTA - ANNO MMVII
PLANTA - ANNO MMVIII
PLANTA - ANNO MMXII (2012 MARULA FRUITS)
PRINCE ALBERT CLASSIC
RENIER - GOLDEN LABEL (LONG GOLDEN FLAKE)
SAMUEL GAWITH - 1792 FLAKE
SAMUEL GAWITH - FULL VIRGINIA FLAKE
SAMUEL GAWITH - BEST BROWN FLAKE
SAMUEL GAWITH - GROUSEMOOR
SAMUEL GAWITH - PERFECTION
SAMUEL GAWITH - SQUADRON LEADER
SAMUEL GAWITH - ST. JAMES FLAKE
SHPC - GREAT HIATUS
SHPC - VR BLEND
SIR WALTER RALEIGH
SOLANI - SILVER FLAKE 660
Need to try list:
ASTLEYS - NO. 44 DARK VIGINIA FLAKE
BALKAN SASIENI
BALKAN SOBRANIE
CAPSTAN
CONDOR READY RUBBED - GREEN
CORNELL & DIEHL - EXHAUSTED ROOSTER
CORNELL & DIEHL - GOOD MORNING
DAN TOBACCO - HAMBORGER VEERMASTER
DAVIDOFF - FLAKE MEDALLIONS
DUNHILL - EARLY MORNING PIPE
DUNHILL - ELIZABETHAN MIXTURE
ESOTERCIA - AND SO TO BED
FRIBOURG & TREYER - CUT VIRGINIA PLUG
FRIBOURG & TREYER - VINTAGE
FROG MORTON - ACROSS THE POND
FROG MORTON - ON THE TOWN
G.L. PEASE - JACKKNIFE PLUG
G.L. PEASE - NAVIGATOR
G.L. PEASE - RENAISSANCE
G.L. PEASE - ROBUSTO
HOLGER DANSKE - ROYAL NAVY FLAKE
IWAN RIES - THREE STAR CORDIAL BUTTERED RUM
J.F. GERMAIN - 1820
J.F. GERMAIN - RICH DARK FLAKE
J.F. GERMAIN - SPECIAL LATAKIA FLAKE
JOHN AYLESBURY - LUXURY FLAKE
MAC BAREN - GOLDEN EXTRA
MC CLELLAND - 2015
MC CLELLAND - BRITISH WOODS
MC CLELLAND - DARK STAR
MC CLELLAND - ST JAMES WOODS
OGDEN - ST. BRUNO FLAKE
PETER STOKKEBYE - ESCUDO NAVY DELUXE
PETERSON - 3P PERFECT PERFECT PLUG
PETERSON - IRISH FLAKE
PETERSON - IRISH OAK
PETERSON - UNIVERSITY FLAKE
PRESBYTERIAN MIXTURE
RATTRAY - BLACK VIRGINIA
RATTRAY - HAL O' THE WYND
RATTRAY - MARLIN FLAKE
SOLANI - 633 VIRGINIA FLAKE W/ PERIQUE
SOLANI - 656 AGED BURLEY FLAKE
WESSEX - BRIGADE CAMPAIGN DARK FLAKE
WESSEX - BROWN VIRGINIA FLAKE
WESSEX - GOLD BRICK VIRGINIA
WESSEX - GOLD VIRGINIA FLAKE
CAPTAIN BLACK - WHITE
CORNELL & DIEHL - 107: HAUNTED BOOKSHOP
CORNELL & DIEHL - 970P: PIRATE KAKE
CORNELL & DIEHL - AUTUMN EVENING
CORNELL & DIEHL - BAYOU MORNING
CORNELL & DIEHL - BILLY BUDD
CORNELL & DIEHL - CAPTAIN BOB'S BLEND
CORNELL & DIEHL - EPIPHANY
CORNELL & DIEHL - NIGHT TRAIN
CORNELL & DIEHL - NUTTY IRISHMAN
CORNELL & DIEHL - OLD JOE KRANTZ
CORNELL & DIEHL - ORIENT EXPRESS
CORNELL & DIEHL - THREE FRIARS
DUNHILL - DELUXE NAVY ROLLS
DUNHILL - MY MIXTURE 965
DUNHILL - NIGHTCAP
DUNHILL - VA FLAKE
ERINMORE - FLAKE
ESOTERCIA - DORCHESTER
ESOTERCIA - DUNBAR
ESOTERCIA - MARGATE
ESOTERCIA - PENZANCE
ESOTERCIA - TILBURY
ESOTERICA - PEMBROKE
ESOTERICA - STONEHAVEN
G. L. PEASE - BARBARY COAST
G. L. PEASE - MALTESE FALCON
GAWITH, HOGGARTH & CO. - ENNERDALE FLAKE
HEARTH & HOME - LARRY'S BLEND
JOHN MIDDLETON - CARTER HALL
LANE LIMITED - 1Q
LANE LIMITED - TK-6
MAC BAREN - 7 SEAS GOLD
MAC BAREN - BURLEY LONDON BLEND
MAC BAREN - HH OLD DARK FIRED
MAC BAREN - SCOTTISH BLEND
MC CLELLAND - FROG MORTN
MC CLELLAND - FROG MORTON ON THE BAYOU
MC CLELLAND - NO. 5100 RED CAKE
MC CLELLAND - NO. 5110 DARK ENGLISH
MC CLELLAND - ORIENTAL # 1
MC CLELLAND - THREE OAKS SYRIAN
MC CLELLAND AVENUE BLEND - (DUNHILL MATCH) A.M. PIPE
MC CLELLAND AVENUE BLEND - (DUNHILL MATCH) NINE TO FIVE 925
MC CLELLAND AVENUE BLEND - (DUNHILL MATCH) P.M. PIPE
MC CLELLAND PERSONAL RESERVE - BLACKWOODS FLAKE
PETER STOKKEBYE - BALKAN SUPREME
PETER STOKKEBYE - LUXURY BULLSEYE FLAKE
PETER STOKKEBYE - LUXURY NAVY FLAKES
PETER STOKKEBYE - LUXURY TWIST FLAKE
PLANTA - ANNO MMVII
PLANTA - ANNO MMVIII
PLANTA - ANNO MMXII (2012 MARULA FRUITS)
PRINCE ALBERT CLASSIC
RENIER - GOLDEN LABEL (LONG GOLDEN FLAKE)
SAMUEL GAWITH - 1792 FLAKE
SAMUEL GAWITH - FULL VIRGINIA FLAKE
SAMUEL GAWITH - BEST BROWN FLAKE
SAMUEL GAWITH - GROUSEMOOR
SAMUEL GAWITH - PERFECTION
SAMUEL GAWITH - SQUADRON LEADER
SAMUEL GAWITH - ST. JAMES FLAKE
SHPC - GREAT HIATUS
SHPC - VR BLEND
SIR WALTER RALEIGH
SOLANI - SILVER FLAKE 660
Need to try list:
ASTLEYS - NO. 44 DARK VIGINIA FLAKE
BALKAN SASIENI
BALKAN SOBRANIE
CAPSTAN
CONDOR READY RUBBED - GREEN
CORNELL & DIEHL - EXHAUSTED ROOSTER
CORNELL & DIEHL - GOOD MORNING
DAN TOBACCO - HAMBORGER VEERMASTER
DAVIDOFF - FLAKE MEDALLIONS
DUNHILL - EARLY MORNING PIPE
DUNHILL - ELIZABETHAN MIXTURE
ESOTERCIA - AND SO TO BED
FRIBOURG & TREYER - CUT VIRGINIA PLUG
FRIBOURG & TREYER - VINTAGE
FROG MORTON - ACROSS THE POND
FROG MORTON - ON THE TOWN
G.L. PEASE - JACKKNIFE PLUG
G.L. PEASE - NAVIGATOR
G.L. PEASE - RENAISSANCE
G.L. PEASE - ROBUSTO
HOLGER DANSKE - ROYAL NAVY FLAKE
IWAN RIES - THREE STAR CORDIAL BUTTERED RUM
J.F. GERMAIN - 1820
J.F. GERMAIN - RICH DARK FLAKE
J.F. GERMAIN - SPECIAL LATAKIA FLAKE
JOHN AYLESBURY - LUXURY FLAKE
MAC BAREN - GOLDEN EXTRA
MC CLELLAND - 2015
MC CLELLAND - BRITISH WOODS
MC CLELLAND - DARK STAR
MC CLELLAND - ST JAMES WOODS
OGDEN - ST. BRUNO FLAKE
PETER STOKKEBYE - ESCUDO NAVY DELUXE
PETERSON - 3P PERFECT PERFECT PLUG
PETERSON - IRISH FLAKE
PETERSON - IRISH OAK
PETERSON - UNIVERSITY FLAKE
PRESBYTERIAN MIXTURE
RATTRAY - BLACK VIRGINIA
RATTRAY - HAL O' THE WYND
RATTRAY - MARLIN FLAKE
SOLANI - 633 VIRGINIA FLAKE W/ PERIQUE
SOLANI - 656 AGED BURLEY FLAKE
WESSEX - BRIGADE CAMPAIGN DARK FLAKE
WESSEX - BROWN VIRGINIA FLAKE
WESSEX - GOLD BRICK VIRGINIA
WESSEX - GOLD VIRGINIA FLAKE