What Would Holmes Have Smoked?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

18 Fresh Estate Pipes
120 Fresh Peterson Pipes
18 Fresh Rossi Pipes
3 Fresh Doctor's Pipes
24 Fresh Erik Stokkebye 4th Generation Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

choch

Starting to Get Obsessed
Aug 10, 2011
128
0
Cincinnati, Ohio USA
This weekend I've been rewatching the excellent Jeremy Brett Sherlock Holmes series (it's the gold standard Holmes IMHO) now that it's available on Netflix streaming. This evening I was browsing some online stores and came across "Peterson Sherlock Holmes" blend, which is described as:
"This mixture is made from an old Irish recipe dating back to 1880 and is one of the finest tobaccos smoked in the time of Sherlock Holmes. The high-quality Virginia and burley blend pocesses all the natural flavor and aroma associated with Premier Virginia tobaccos"
This got me thinking, what were high end pipe tobaccos like in 1890's England, and what would Holmes (were he a real person) have been smoking? Any thoughts??
Cheers,
Craig

 

kabong30

Can't Leave
Jun 2, 2012
329
2
I'm in the same boat on watching Holmes. Just got started on season 2 :D I'm also a big fan of the new BBC series but there is decidedly less pipe smoking (read, none).

 

schmitzbitz

Lifer
Jan 13, 2011
1,165
2
Port Coquitlam, B.C.
A strong black shag kept in a Persian slipper hung on the mantle. Usually smoked in a clay, oily black with use, but sometimes in a "cherry wood" dark with age. As Holmes was an addict of the strongest sort, this would likely be a very strong blend - I can envision something like Tambolaka fitting the bill.
Watson smoked ships tobacco (a rope, I suspect) prior to his engagement, however switched to Arcadia mixture to appease the fairer sex.
McClelland has a take on both - and a third tobacco only mentioned by room-note in the tome, Honeydew.

 

cortezattic

Lifer
Nov 19, 2009
15,147
7,637
Chicago, IL
Like schmitzbitz alludes, it must needs have been rugged stuff. Think nicotine, not nuance!

I seem to recall from one of the stories that Dr. Watson complained about the room note, or perhaps just the choking volume of smoke.

 

zanthal

Lifer
Dec 3, 2011
1,835
0
Pleasanton, CA
I thought some mention of the type of tobacco had to have been mentioned in the books (which I have not read).
I don't remember where it's based, but there is Sherlock Holmes Pipe Club... I'm smoking Great Hiatus right now actually.

 

irishsmoker

Lifer
Feb 14, 2012
1,177
0
Think of the most dry and fowl smelling nicotine heavy tobacco you can think of, and that is what Holmes would've smoked.

 

baronsamedi

Lifer
May 4, 2011
5,688
5
Dallas
What he smoked was probably strong and cheap. Probably tasted like a black shag RYO from the drug store and loaded with nicotine!

 

ohiopuffer

Can't Leave
May 18, 2012
351
0
Being a genius wouldn't he probably have experimented blending his own tobacco?Just a thought as I do not know alot about Holmes I have never read any books but a friend has suggested I watch the series you guys are talking about.

 

mluyckx

Lifer
Dec 5, 2011
1,958
3
Texas
Straight Dark Fired Kentucky Leaf
I agree based on reading the books that it would have been a dark, strong, shag-cut, heavy nicotine tobacco with a unpleasant room note. I have one.. Gawith & Hoggarth Kendal Kentucky
Shag: check

Dark: check (although not quite black)

Strong: check (it's 100% dark fired Kentucky)

Nicotine: check (it can give me a buzz.. and I smoke nails for 30+ years)

Foul smelling: If I believe my wife.. double check
MIght be on to something.... all I need is a old "disreputable" clay, black with age, or an oily briar :puffpipe:

 

schmitzbitz

Lifer
Jan 13, 2011
1,165
2
Port Coquitlam, B.C.
Good call there Mick; I think you are onto something - according to the Samuel Gawith site, Gawith Hoggarth first opened their doors under the G&H name in 1878, focusing on "twist tobacco" while Samuel Gawith focused primarily on snuff.

We also know that Conan Doyle was a student until 1881; then spent time at sea on a whaler prior to opening his failing medical practice in 1882. It was here that he first began to pen the iconic detective stories, with "A Study in Scarlett" first published in 1886; making the good doctor (and by extension, the detective) contemporaries of G&H tobaccos. What I can't determine, however, is just when G&H blends were introduced - SG has a much better history available - and just how far-reaching G&H blends were - I can't find any evidence of A.C.D. having lived in the Kendal region, but rather Sussex, Hindhead, and Edinburgh (which isn't to say he wasn't influenced by the Lake District; I just can't find solid evidence to support this).

 

lraisch

Part of the Furniture Now
Jul 4, 2011
609
1,191
Granite Falls, Washington state
McLelland's makes their "221B series" based on blends mentioned in the canon. The Black Shag is awful stuff, though probably just as Holmes prefered (remember he also smoked cigars and cigarettes).
The Arcadia (Watson's blend) is quite good, a nice mild English.
I also enjoyed Honeydew to a certain extent.

 

zanthal

Lifer
Dec 3, 2011
1,835
0
Pleasanton, CA
I think he liked "Walnut" [:laughat:] You know, something he could have bought at CVS
hobiedog has a good point. What makes Sherlock Holmes notable is his passion for logical deduction, not his choice of tobacco.
But Sherlock Holmes Pipe Club's Great Hiatus is the one blend that I could actually conjure up any sense of the Holmes stories while smoking. I'm sure it's entirely subliminal because of the name
Is the Jeremy Brett TV series any better or worse than this latest incarnation?

 
Status
Not open for further replies.