Tin Star is just one of the many brands of bagged chaff passed off as pipe tobacco to take advantage of a tobacco tax structure that will probably go away very soon. Not only is it nowhere near a tolerable pipe tobacco, it is low-rent garbage of a hobo smoke as cigarette tobacco, as well.
The way I understand it is this: factory-made cigarettes started to be taxed at a much higher rate than all other types of tobacco product, since they were the starting point of the creeping incrementalism toward a total prohibition that the dumbshit slackjaws who inhabit this country fall for EVERY SINGLE TIME.
Cigarette smokers on a budget looked around and noticed that winos, inmates, a few old timers and a handful of boutique tobacco snobs were rolling their own; always had been. Since the tobacco was so much cheaper, even for the good stuff like Drum, people started giving it a try. But the skill level ran from somebody's crusty old gramps in the back of a pickup, bumping down a dirt road in Wyoming rolling a smoke with one hand and shooting coyotes with the other all the way to staring at the papers and wondering how they turn into a cigarette. So the various rolling machines, tube stuffing devices, etc. became popular, and RYO really took off. With RYO now a big business, some of the sellers noticed pipe tobacco was taxed at a lower rate than loose cigarette tobacco. Voila- cheaper RYO tobacco, labeled as something it's not.
Now, don't get me wrong. I understand trying to weasel out of a punitive tax structure if you can. I just don't think the RYO guys have done us any favors by stealing our label for their product. Nothing gets governmental noses a'twitchin' like the smell of money they haven't stolen yet. This mislabeling is only going to accelerate the demise of the multi-tiered tax on tobaccos, which is beneficial to us as pipe smokers.
I've typed enough, so I guess I'll take on the usual devil's advocate and automatic contrarian crowd as they come. Well, except to say pre-emptively, yes, I know many tobaccos were marketed and used for decades as being "for pipe and cigarette", like my beloved Prince Albert.