That's a first

lukester

Might Stick Around

Jan 12, 2011

67

0

• Jul 24, 2011

• #1

I popped a tin of new tobacco to try a few days ago and I did not like. In fact I wont even finish it!!!! First time this has ever happened. Usually i finish and will never purchase again. It is somewhat strange how I enjoy more 2 or 3 star rating tobacco's over the highly recommended 5 star one's.

 

pstlpkr

Lifer

Dec 14, 2009

9,694

31

Birmingham, AL

• Jul 24, 2011

• #2

Lukester... What is it?

 

fullbent

Can't Leave

May 6, 2011

463

0

• Jul 24, 2011

• #3

Lukester... What is it?

Click to expand...

Would like to know myself

 

hobie1dog

Lifer

Jun 5, 2010

6,888

233

67

Cornelius, NC

• Jul 24, 2011

• #4

Must have been Walnut :laughat:

 

lukester

Might Stick Around

Jan 12, 2011

67

0

• Jul 24, 2011

• #5

It is G L Pease Triple Play. I really like Jackknife Plug so I thought I would give this a try. It wounds my heart that I really don't like it. I guess I can't like them all! Please do not let my own opinion discourage anyone from trying.

 

fullbent

Can't Leave

May 6, 2011

463

0

• Jul 24, 2011

• #6

Oh wow! I love triple play....That is very strange

 

zunismoke

Starting to Get Obsessed

Nov 3, 2010

179

0

NC

• Jul 24, 2011

• #7

Everyone has different tastes! I do not like any of the Frog Morton blends. These are a favorite of many pipers! Not me. You just need to experiment and find what you like.

 

pawpaw

Lifer

Jun 25, 2011

1,492

1

cleveland NC

• Jul 24, 2011

• #8

"It is somewhat strange how I enjoy more 2 or 3 star rating tobacco's over the highly recommended 5 star one's."
i can relate to that.... not all tounges are created equal

 

puffy

Lifer

Dec 24, 2010

2,511

98

North Carolina

• Jul 24, 2011

• #9

Is it the type of tobacco that you don't like,or just a particular blend? For example I have yet to find a straight Virginia that I enjoy smoking.

 

thesmokindragon

Lifer

Jul 12, 2011

4,135

4,216

• Jul 24, 2011

• #10

yeah I loved jackknife plug (filled big bowl of it first time and it sucker-punched me goooooooooood...love a good Nic-Slap'in now and then)
Hi ; have you tried 660: Silver Flake? It does have some Kentucky in it but IMO/Damn good bacci

 

lukester

Might Stick Around

Jan 12, 2011

67

0

• Jul 24, 2011

• #11

It is the blend. It reminds me of burning electronics. and you need a hammer and chisel to tamp it.

 

rigmedic1

Lifer

May 29, 2011

3,896

75

• Jul 24, 2011

• #12

I am not a big fan of C&D blends, but my son in law loves em. Doesn't stop me from trying them though. They tend to make me nauseous. Lol, suffering is good for the soul though.

 

pstlpkr

Lifer

Dec 14, 2009

9,694

31

Birmingham, AL

• Jul 24, 2011

• #13

Everybody's tastes are different... Me I'm not too partial to C&D 417-P Night Train.

A lot of guys love it.

 

riptide

Part of the Furniture Now

Jul 27, 2010

662

12

Colorado

• Jul 24, 2011

• #14

We all have blends we don't like I tossed a tin a Haunted book shop once it was like smoking not book paper to me.

 

matchstickman

Lifer

Jul 15, 2011

2,363

31

• Jul 25, 2011

• #15

Ive tried Cornell and Diehl tins that most people rave over and when I smoked them, the tongue bite was so bad I could even do a second light. Some people are just that way ::